Emag wrote: ↑15 Jul 2025, 14:58
I think RedBull right now is in a similar situation to McLaren early 2010s.
McLaren lost Mercedes and it turned out they were way more important than McLaren cared to admit. It just took a couple of years for them to start to go downhill.
Similarly, RedBull lost Dietrich and its turning out he was way more important than it appeared.
I hope they don’t make McLaren’s mistake and wait too long to act. Sure, Horner’s scandal didn’t help, but this team was coming apart before that. I am not entirely convinced firing Horner was the right move, but on the other hand, it was kind of self-inflicted in his part as well.
I personally would be surprised if Max stays at RedBull right now, but lets wait and see how things will transpire.
I totally agree here, and I think there is an element of this too in why Newey left - I do tend to believe a part of it was he had a falling how with Horner.
But under Dietrich the were almost a privateer team there was no board controlling them no corporate interests looking at the money spend on the investment and returns etc - I know Newey commented that was something he liked you didn't really have to convince him too much to upgrade facilities if it would improve the team
I think even if the Horner scandal is what broke it, I am not really convinced he would have stayed around with where the team management is heading.
On Horner's sacking I think it depends exactly what is happening behind the scenes. If it was a power play by the Austrian side of RB and the Versthapphens I feel a little comfortable about it in that I think he is being used as a bit. of a scape goat, not entirely without blame as I think he is responsible for their downfall too. But I don't think much really gets done without Markos influence I doubt Dietrich pulls out of the Porsche deal without Markos advice and go down the path of RBPT, I think to some extent his influence is still all over RBR he has always been the spokesperson on upcoming updates. The Porsche deal was probably designed to stop this kinda conflict. I do think overall Horner would have had more influence and this blame.
However if Horner had lost the confidence of some key staff in the engineering teams than I can more easily understand the reasoning and justify it even if its a little harsh.