Emag wrote: ↑08 Dec 2025, 13:17
Ferrari needs to accept some accountability as well for losing the winter development war, while also losing the in-season development game badly too. It's why Elkan's words were particularly annoying to hear for me. How can you say the car is fine and blame it on the drivers?
Remember where RedBull was at the beginning of the season? Their car was all over the place and very inconsistent in spite of having glimpses of competitiveness. Max is Max. He didn't change in the second half of the season. What changed was his car. RedBull turned it around with their Monza upgrade and the car was good enough that it allowed Max the chance to fight at the very least. What did Ferrari do? They spent half a season developing a new rear suspension that changed absolutely nothing about the relative performance of the car. They got outdone hard by RedBull and I am not even going to mention the fact that McLaren was so far ahead, they won both the championships without bringing any significant upgrade to the car throughout the season. That was the same team which finished just 14 points ahead of them one year ago.
Ferrari and all the other teams lost against Mclaren.
Ferrari lost this year development race against Red Bull because they stopped developing the car at the end of April.
If you compare to Red Bull (and even Mercedes), it is not fair actually, as they brought another 2-3 floor iterations and also a more flexible front wing, which was what was the holy grail in the Venturi era and what upped Red Bull at Mclaren level.
Red Bull itself admitted it was going to cost for 2026 development, but they were happy to pay the price.
Ferrari realized early the car was so flawed that with the regs change in 2026 it was going to be pointless to develop it and no wise man can blame them for that.
Red Bull had a flawed car in 2024 and a flawed car in 2025 that only looks good now because Mclaren stopped developing at Silverstone and only in the hands of Max.
Mercedes had another flawed car, they were one second slower than Ferrari at AD, with all the SF-25 flaws.
If Ferrari failed, the same should apply to Red Bull and Mercedes, if the objective is not just a few wins, but to go for the titles.
Again, if Mclaren had developed the car as RB did, they seal the championship at Austin.
At the moment, only Mclaren can call itself a true top team, because at the factory they are the benchmark.
Then, regarding Toto, in 2026 at some point he will have to explain why a customer team (Mclaren) is ahead of them for the third season in a row, because that is what it is going to happen as Mclaren wisely concentrated on 2026 very early, as big as it was its advantage.