Badger wrote: ↑09 Nov 2025, 21:43
Emag wrote: ↑09 Nov 2025, 21:24
Badger wrote: ↑09 Nov 2025, 21:18
It's not about the hards being good, it's about not doing an extra pit stop and losing a bunch of positions. Doing 10-15 more laps on the hard and then medium-medium to the end would have been preferable.
How many positions did he lose though? He was on hards behind a bunch of cars. He would have been on a DRS train with suboptimal tires (Max even said so himself, the car didnt feel good on Hards). He then pits, comes out a couple of positions behind, but in VSC or SC conditions, so he didn't lose out as much time as you would normally lose from a pitstop. After pitting he not only has tire delta, but he is also on the best tire of the weekend, while being free to push as hard as he could. He was essentially in sync with the front runners at that point, but with tire delta while also having gotten rid of one of the worse tire sets of the weekend, so he could keep fitting mediums if he wanted to.
It's just hypotheticals at this point, but I don't think he would have made the podium with hards-medium-medium. Or if he did, it wouldn't have been as "easy".
He lost 5 positions and 14 seconds.
Did you miss the start? You realise Max was making up a bunch of positions on the hard tyre right? You also realize he had 6 soft runners and 1 hard runner ahead of him before the puncture? The soft tyre was sh**, they would have come towards him if had stayed out another 10-15 laps.
I feel like you're not actually explaining how an extra stop and losing track position actually helped. We understand the medium was the preferred tyre, he would have taken full advantage of that on the optimal strategy too, just with one less stop. I think he would have easily finished P2 doing that, and made Lando sweat as I said originally.
I just checked again, he went from P13 to P16 and ~7 seconds back from P15. P15-P13 were covered by 0.3+0.7s at the restart after the VSC. The rest pretty much within DRS distance of each other up until the Mercs. Oh and one of the cars ahead after the restart being Tsuonda, so discount him completely on top of that.
So basically, lost 8 seconds from his position to swap some horrible tires and get tire delta. He was within Lewis' DRS by lap 12 by the way with the VSC restart being at lap 9. Because the field is bunched up in the first couple of laps, he was literally gaining buckets of time on the cars ahead, so essentially, in 3 laps, he was back where he started but while being on a much better position strategy-wise with tire delta on everyone ahead and free to push as hard as he could for the rest of the race.
I fail to see where the disadvantage is.