diffuser wrote: ↑20 Jul 2022, 23:07
Piastri is an unknown. He has the abilities to be the next Verstappen or the next Vandorne. Only time will tell.
The only way to tell is to put Piastri in the car. It would be untenable for the un-retired Alonso (despite driving well) to block the progression of not just one but two young drivers, Piastri AND Sargeant. It would be best for F1 overall for Sargeant to debut in the Williams and Piastri in the Alpine. [Look how well Alonso making a place for Norris went after all! That has been very good for the sport.]
A placement of Piastri at Williams, especially a two-year placement based on a two-year Alonso-Alpine contract, is merely shifting the problem of no race seat from Piastri to Sargeant, which is not helpful in the slightest really!
Alonsismo wrote: ↑19 Jul 2022, 20:53
Alpine can create a 2012 lotus for the next year, and with this car, Fernando can win the championship.
Except that Piastri is likely to be driving the Alpine (F1 car) next season.
Piastri-Alpine and Sargeant-Williams is really the only logical solution for these two teams and their promising juniors,
not a loan that blocks Sargeant's path. Alonso might, however, be driving for Aston Martin if Vettel retires.
Edit -- Of course Alpine also has a Le Mans team, so Alonso could drive for Alpine there if he would prefer to stay with the French marque rather than return to Toyota Gazoo Racing. Laurent Rossi has apparently made a comment on that topic:
We talked about the fact that Fernando is a legend of the sport, but also a legend of the Renault Group. For us, he’s the champion. He was always going to have a seat in LMDh the day he switches, he will be welcome, it’s his team. So obviously this is part of the discussion.
https://www.autosport.com/f1/news/alons ... /10342110/
So Piastri > BWT Alpine F1 Team, Alonso > Alpine Elf Team could be part of the Alpine "El Plan".
Alonso Fan wrote: ↑20 Jul 2022, 19:28
But they do lose out, not much but ultimately they get rid of their best or 2nd best driver and keep the 3rd best because they made him a long term deal.
Ocon has a contract, he will be driving the car until 2024. It is what it is, that deal is done, it's the other seat which is vacant for 2023.