Fluido wrote: ↑17 Mar 2025, 11:04
Lewis is too old, you can't go against time. No old driver performed well, I think he is only destroying his legacy, he had to retire after the historic 2021-theft.
Conveniently forgetting how good Hamilton was in 2022 and especially 2023.
He's doing just fine still. He might not be a match for Leclerc, Norris or Verstappen at this point, but he's still a great driver and is far from destroying his legacy.
Also frankly I think the importance of age is heavily overstated. I think the reason that "old" drivers usually end up performing worse has much more to do with complacency and familial obligations than it has to do with actual age.
Football players or other pro athletes start getting worse with age because their bodies simply can't keep up with the insane demands of elite sports anymore. Formula 1 doesn't set those requirements on the body. Physicality in F1 is a lot more binary than traditional sports. Either your body can cope with the demands or it can't. It isn't a slow degradation over several years where you become more and more injury prone and lose a bit of endurance.
With F1 it's simply a question of whether your body can cope or not. If you're strong enough, you get very few additional benefits from getting even stronger. It isn't like football where more endurance or a faster run speed is always a good thing and the slow degradation of your ability to run in your mid to late 30s causes you to become washed.
Obviously you suffer a slight degradation of your reaction speed and stuff as you age, but Alonso is the oldest driver on the grid and still has cat like reflexes and is still among the best starters on the grid.
If anything I think age has very little actual effect on your ability to actually race, and has a lot more to do with the loss of neuroplasticity. Older drivers struggle a bit more to adapt to new car behaviour, but even then Alonso has adapted really well to this regulation set. Hamilton has struggled more, but I think that has more to do with his unwillingness to actually spend time in the sim, which has allegedly changed with his move to Ferrari.
Hamilton can perform if he wants to put in the work. He says he wants to work hard, thus he should be able to perform. Age has a very small impact on your ability to perform in F1 compared to traditional sports.