I’m not buying the need for a narrow operating window as an requirement for a fast car…
The current WCC leading car has a wide operating window and is certainly not slow.
Not too much to disagree with here , the success did allow them to justify it. But I think particularly early on in the setup phase it was a huge plus that then it was almost a pet project for Dietrich and who knows how things would have panned out without Newey.Seanspeed wrote: ↑15 Jul 2025, 18:52Initially, Red Bull were pretty brash in how they went about things, very built on their sort of fun and adrenaline-fueled brand values. This wasn't just in the PR world, they really did run their team in a looser way, and they were backed by big bucks. It's exactly what got them to offer Newey the freedom to build the technical side of the team to his liking, when most other teams would have been too rigid and established to do so, or simply lacked the resources to make it meaningful.Watto wrote: ↑15 Jul 2025, 15:28But under Dietrich the were almost a privateer team there was no board controlling them no corporate interests looking at the money spend on the investment and returns etc - I know Newey commented that was something he liked you didn't really have to convince him too much to upgrade facilities if it would improve the team
But the big spending and 'corporate-free' attitudes would not have lasted super long if the success wasn't there. If they weren't winning, eventually RB higher ups would absolutely have stepped in and started questioning their big investment into the sport as a constructor. And it wouldn't have taken until Dietrich's death or anything, this would have likely happened way, way earlier. Without Newey, they might well have been out of the sport by like 2015. Obviously we cant know what they'd have done without him, but it almost assuredly would have never been anything like what they did ultimately achieve.
Newey was always their golden goose.
Horner was the one that vetoed the Porsche deal, Mateschitz, Marko, AustriaRB wanted the Porsche deal to go ahead.Watto wrote: ↑15 Jul 2025, 15:28But I don't think much really gets done without Markos influence I doubt Dietrich pulls out of the Porsche deal without Markos advice and go down the path of RBPT, I think to some extent his influence is still all over RBR he has always been the spokesperson on upcoming updates. The Porsche deal was probably designed to stop this kinda conflict. I do think overall Horner would have had more influence and this blame.
Dee wrote: ↑16 Jul 2025, 21:32Horner was the one that vetoed the Porsche deal, Mateschitz, Marko, AustriaRB wanted the Porsche deal to go ahead.Watto wrote: ↑15 Jul 2025, 15:28But I don't think much really gets done without Markos influence I doubt Dietrich pulls out of the Porsche deal without Markos advice and go down the path of RBPT, I think to some extent his influence is still all over RBR he has always been the spokesperson on upcoming updates. The Porsche deal was probably designed to stop this kinda conflict. I do think overall Horner would have had more influence and this blame.
https://gp-news.net/the-porsche-factor- ... -red-bull/
"Christian Horner’s decision to veto the proposed partnership between Red Bull and Porsche—at a time when the deal was nearly finalized—created deep resentment, particularly with Mateschitz. Although the Red Bull co-founder was already battling terminal illness at the time and unable to act decisively, the fallout from that decision was lasting. Had Mateschitz been in full health, it is highly plausible that Christian Horner would have been removed from his leadership positions much earlier.Christian Horner reportedly wanted to acquire shares in Red Bull Racing’s motorsport division, mirroring the ownership model of Mercedes-AMG Petronas Formula One Team, where Team Principal Toto Wolff owns one-third of the team. However, Horner’s request for equity was denied."
Also RBPT was started in Feb 2021 to take over the Honda engines because Honda were pulling out, it wasn't until the Porsche deal collapsed that RB decided to make their own engine with Ford as their partner...
Said new Team Principal is also a big supporter of Yuki. I don't think anything will have been decided yet.
No, he has...POWER....
Wasn't Baku the race Checo was on for a potential podium, possibly a win, if he hadn't had that unnecessary crash with Sainz toward the end of the race? Checo had it in the window and was pretty quick. So when it's in the right window, it can be fast.Ashwinv16 wrote: ↑15 Jul 2025, 01:36The exact words where said by Sergio Perez during the Azerbaijan free practice interview stating he warned them about it in Spanish GP in 2024 but they ignored him (Well mostly Christian Horner decided to ignore him)MYsee wrote: ↑15 Jul 2025, 00:35This sounds like the story for the RB20, not the RB21.Watto wrote: ↑14 Jul 2025, 15:41I would certainly put this down as rumour but David Croft had claimed Red Bull ignored warning the RB21 would be quick but undrivable I would say there is some classic media exaggeration here
https://www.crash.net/f1/news/1077087/1 ... ble-f1-car
Seanspeed wrote: ↑15 Jul 2025, 18:52Absolutely not. Mateschitz was a motorsport junkie, unlike Football. He invested his private money in a lot of things around the RB circuit, as he was born there. Never ever he would had sold the team, that was his passion.Watto wrote: ↑15 Jul 2025, 15:28But the big spending and 'corporate-free' attitudes would not have lasted super long if the success wasn't there. If they weren't winning, eventually RB higher ups would absolutely have stepped in and started questioning their big investment into the sport as a constructor. And it wouldn't have taken until Dietrich's death or anything, this would have likely happened way, way earlier. Without Newey, they might well have been out of the sport by like 2015. Obviously we cant know what they'd have done without him, but it almost assuredly would have never been anything like what they did ultimately achieve.
Newey was always their golden goose.
Absolutely not. Mateschitz was a motorsport junkie, unlike Football. He invested his private money in a lot of things around the RB circuit, as he was born there. Never ever he would had sold the team, that was his passion. And he had the contractual Power to decide all on his own.But the big spending and 'corporate-free' attitudes would not have lasted super long if the success wasn't there. If they weren't winning, eventually RB higher ups would absolutely have stepped in and started questioning their big investment into the sport as a constructor. And it wouldn't have taken until Dietrich's death or anything, this would have likely happened way, way earlier. Without Newey, they might well have been out of the sport by like 2015. Obviously we cant know what they'd have done without him, but it almost assuredly would have never been anything like what they did ultimately achieve.
Newey was always their golden goose.
From one side, you could see it that it's really not his concern anymore what happens after his passing. He is done with this world and it makes no difference to him if RedBull goes bankrupt tomorrow. But I get what you mean.TeamKoolGreen wrote: ↑17 Jul 2025, 22:01In the end, what we've witnessed since 2022 is simply a catastrophic failure of succession planning By Dietrich Mateschitz. Not even 6 months after his passing, the empire started falling apart from the inside out.
If he wanted the team to last, he needed much more planning and ideas to make it work. Separate RBR into a separate unit. Give Horner and Marko shares. Force them to make it work like they did for 20 years.