venkyhere wrote: ↑05 Dec 2025, 00:59
This is 'absolute cinema' , they are even confused about who should say what. Why doesn't Mclaren as a whole just say "we discuss all that internally" and stop the Question from proceeding any further ? Apart from the 'race operations team', even the 'PR preparation team' deserve to be fired, looks like.
No, I think this is an absolute no. There is no better PR team in F1 than with McLaren. They kept it clean all season in a perfect way, stated several times this year. And the press release about data sharing and interventions is again the same example, sounds super nice like racing and covers all aspects, even the last minute intervention like the micro management they had all season.
I think rather the above is again an example of the strict management. They do not need to talk about anything with the drivers. They have their coded comms and clear instructions on when to stand down. The drivers just do what the pit wall is saying, so nothing to talk about.
FittingMechanics wrote: ↑05 Dec 2025, 08:17
That is so stupid. So instead of finding the best setup they will each try and find it and risk being exposed by Verstappen.
I hope whoever is driving these decisions is ready to take the fall if Verstappen beats them.
What an idiotic approach.
I think this is overreacting...for three reasons:
- I think this is a nice attempt to look good on PR. But the big question behind is still if they wanted "to avoid giving either driver any advantage", why didn't they do the same mid season when just driving against each other? Why this late PR stunt?
- Merc went from a completely open data strategy to some restrictions when Ham and Ros were only battling each other for WDC. It basically did not have any bad influence on anything.
- Running the same sim on the same rig...in the end running the same car, the same floor and wings...why should there in any case be a big difference? These guys know what they do and have the same technical help in the factory in the background. Setting up these cars goes much deeper than just the race engineers. Another Nothingburger.
Edit: I need to correct a bit the point on stupidity. You are right: Piastri is not driving in FP1. Not sharing the data is not only stupid, but highly unfair given that this is the only race where they change the approach. So you are right...this is absolutely nothing you do on the last race.