Are 2026 F1 regulations broken? How to fix them?

A place to discuss the characteristics of the cars in Formula One, both current as well as historical. Laptimes, driver worshipping and team chatter do not belong here.
Rikhart
Rikhart
32
Joined: 10 Feb 2009, 20:21

Are 2026 F1 regulations broken? How to fix them?

Post

So we now have two of the most notorious drivers in the sport, Lewis Hamilton and Max Verstappen, openly criticizing the current regulations, in quite strong terms.

From the reports I have been reading, I fully agree with them, it seems you might benefit more from being an accountant of sorts, rather than a talented driver, because of the extreme management that is needed to maximize the energy available on each lap.

So, how could we fix this (especially in the short term)? An easy solution might be to reduce the battery on the overall power of the cars, or even eliminate it altogether, now that we are using sustainable fuels, but I can't see that being done in a short timeframe.

dialtone
dialtone
139
Joined: 25 Feb 2019, 01:31

Re: Are 2026 F1 regulations broken? How to fix them?

Post

They aren't broken and there's nothing to fix?

The only measurement that matters is what kind of racing it produces, not if 2 guys like them.

Rikhart
Rikhart
32
Joined: 10 Feb 2009, 20:21

Re: Are 2026 F1 regulations broken? How to fix them?

Post

dialtone wrote:
12 Feb 2026, 19:15
They aren't broken and there's nothing to fix?

The only measurement that matters is what kind of racing it produces, not if 2 guys like them.
Do you personally enjoy things like "super-clipping" and lift and coast even in qualifying laps?

I for one, hate them.

Also, please consider you're not just talking about "2 guys", you're talking about the elite of F1 in the last decade or so. What they say carries a lot of weight.

User avatar
chrisc90
41
Joined: 23 Feb 2022, 21:22

Re: Are 2026 F1 regulations broken? How to fix them?

Post

I agree. If these cars can’t be driven at full chat all the time then where is the fun? These drivers are natural born racers, They want to drive flat out everywhere, pushing the limits and driving on the edge.

We’ve all seen the onboards from testing where the cars look completely lifeless mid corner.

Bring back the screaming V10’s
Mess with the Bull - you get the horns.

gearboxtrouble
gearboxtrouble
4
Joined: 17 Jan 2026, 19:17

Re: Are 2026 F1 regulations broken? How to fix them?

Post

Some level of energy management should always be part of racing. It was in the MGUH era but I think this current set of regs pushes it too far if drivers have to lift and coast on qualifying laps at some circuits. They can and should make some changes for 27 to improve things and stop someone like Max from leaving for another series. Simplest solution would be to increase the energy flow budget by 20% to boost ICE power to ~700 hp and to lower the electric deployment cap to 300 hp while keeping the ES size the same. This should be enough to let drivers push at most tracks without having to resort to FE style energy management to maximize laptime.

Badger
Badger
30
Joined: 22 Sep 2025, 17:00

Re: Are 2026 F1 regulations broken? How to fix them?

Post

My initial reaction is that the "lack of fun" driving them is translating to a lack of fun watching them. The car itself is way less exciting to watch on push laps. As for the racing we will see, we did get a bit of a taste today when Lando was following George. It didn't look amazing to say the least, he could not get close despite being faster.

User avatar
bananapeel23
23
Joined: 14 Feb 2023, 22:43
Location: Sweden

Re: Are 2026 F1 regulations broken? How to fix them?

Post

Rikhart wrote:
12 Feb 2026, 19:13
So we now have two of the most notorious drivers in the sport, Lewis Hamilton and Max Verstappen, openly criticizing the current regulations, in quite strong terms.

From the reports I have been reading, I fully agree with them, it seems you might benefit more from being an accountant of sorts, rather than a talented driver, because of the extreme management that is needed to maximize the energy available on each lap.

So, how could we fix this (especially in the short term)? An easy solution might be to reduce the battery on the overall power of the cars, or even eliminate it altogether, now that we are using sustainable fuels, but I can't see that being done in a short timeframe.
Realistically the goal should be to have slow enough deployment to not get clipping on normal laps, but to become vulnerable if you overuse overtake mode. I think this could be achieved with sharper deployment dropoff at high speed, perhaps beginning even at 150-200 km/h and increased energy flow to compensate. I suggest roughly 3600 MJ/hr (20% more than currently, about 20% less than 2014-2025). The sharper deployment dropoff means you don't clip as heavily on the straights, while the increase in energy flow keeps the top speed up. Overtake mode might need minor tweaks to prevent 1100hp monsters going 400kph with overtake and DRS, but that should be relatively simple.

The result is that the electrical energy is primarily used for acceleration out of corners and overtaking, while the ICE provides the majority of the grunt at high speed. This allows them to keep the nominal electrical output at 350kW, even if it's only at low speed. The FIA could probably still claim 45/55 if they wanted to, despite it being as untrue as 50/50 is today. Overall the cars might end up a little faster over a lap than they are now, but still slower than last year.

This would likely require a quick decision from the FIA and only come into effect for 2027, but it would largely resolve the issues with these engines. If they do this I also hope that they do something to make the cars a bit more interesting mid-corner as well. They look like sports cars in turn 1 and 4.

Another alternative to improve the racing is to simply cap deployment at something like 250kW, while still allowing harvesting at 350kW. Then you once again increase energy flow to compensate, potentially also making small tweaks to make the ICE more thermally efficient. When you can't deploy as much, you can deploy for longer, which will reduce the complexity of deployment and harvesting algorithms, which should reduce clipping.
Last edited by bananapeel23 on 12 Feb 2026, 19:59, edited 3 times in total.

dialtone
dialtone
139
Joined: 25 Feb 2019, 01:31

Re: Are 2026 F1 regulations broken? How to fix them?

Post

Rikhart wrote:
12 Feb 2026, 19:20
dialtone wrote:
12 Feb 2026, 19:15
They aren't broken and there's nothing to fix?

The only measurement that matters is what kind of racing it produces, not if 2 guys like them.
Do you personally enjoy things like "super-clipping" and lift and coast even in qualifying laps?

I for one, hate them.

Also, please consider you're not just talking about "2 guys", you're talking about the elite of F1 in the last decade or so. What they say carries a lot of weight.
These are not issues with the Formula per se. All the limits on deployment and energy recovery are what makes this a management formula in your eyes (and clearly theirs).

I personally see nothing wrong with a driver having to handle more than just pressing 2 pedals and going around the track, cars have become massively more advanced, Lauda was wrong in saying that a monkey could drive a modern F1 car, but this is the same energy from Max. Technology is moving forward, criticizing the technology is not the way, criticize the way the rules are put together if you really need and increase the limits so you can push harder.

FittingMechanics
FittingMechanics
20
Joined: 19 Feb 2019, 12:10

Re: Are 2026 F1 regulations broken? How to fix them?

Post

Just increase allowed charge to 10 MJ or so. We'd get full out quali runs with 0 recharging. This should be easy to do.

In the race you'd need to recharge but maybe they could allow off throttle engine use (to a degree) for recharging so you don't have to lift and recharge.

Badger
Badger
30
Joined: 22 Sep 2025, 17:00

Re: Are 2026 F1 regulations broken? How to fix them?

Post

FittingMechanics wrote:
12 Feb 2026, 20:24
Just increase allowed charge to 10 MJ or so. We'd get full out quali runs with 0 recharging. This should be easy to do.

In the race you'd need to recharge but maybe they could allow off throttle engine use (to a degree) for recharging so you don't have to lift and recharge.
That would require a 2,5x larger battery and would solve none of the long run issues.

dialtone
dialtone
139
Joined: 25 Feb 2019, 01:31

Re: Are 2026 F1 regulations broken? How to fix them?

Post

Badger wrote:
12 Feb 2026, 20:28
FittingMechanics wrote:
12 Feb 2026, 20:24
Just increase allowed charge to 10 MJ or so. We'd get full out quali runs with 0 recharging. This should be easy to do.

In the race you'd need to recharge but maybe they could allow off throttle engine use (to a degree) for recharging so you don't have to lift and recharge.
That would require a 2,5x larger battery and would solve none of the long run issues.
No it doesn't. Battery is 4MJ and max lap energy recovery is 9MJ at the moment.

Badger
Badger
30
Joined: 22 Sep 2025, 17:00

Re: Are 2026 F1 regulations broken? How to fix them?

Post

dialtone wrote:
12 Feb 2026, 20:33
Badger wrote:
12 Feb 2026, 20:28
FittingMechanics wrote:
12 Feb 2026, 20:24
Just increase allowed charge to 10 MJ or so. We'd get full out quali runs with 0 recharging. This should be easy to do.

In the race you'd need to recharge but maybe they could allow off throttle engine use (to a degree) for recharging so you don't have to lift and recharge.
That would require a 2,5x larger battery and would solve none of the long run issues.
No it doesn't. Battery is 4MJ and max lap energy recovery is 9MJ at the moment.
Maybe you should read the comment I was replying to.

dialtone
dialtone
139
Joined: 25 Feb 2019, 01:31

Re: Are 2026 F1 regulations broken? How to fix them?

Post

Badger wrote:
12 Feb 2026, 20:35
dialtone wrote:
12 Feb 2026, 20:33
Badger wrote:
12 Feb 2026, 20:28

That would require a 2,5x larger battery and would solve none of the long run issues.
No it doesn't. Battery is 4MJ and max lap energy recovery is 9MJ at the moment.
Maybe you should read the comment I was replying to.
I did read it, the comment is saying to raise the 9MJ limit to 10MJ, you don't need a 10MJ battery to do that, at worst a 5MJ maintains the same ratio.

Badger
Badger
30
Joined: 22 Sep 2025, 17:00

Re: Are 2026 F1 regulations broken? How to fix them?

Post

dialtone wrote:
12 Feb 2026, 20:36
Badger wrote:
12 Feb 2026, 20:35
dialtone wrote:
12 Feb 2026, 20:33


No it doesn't. Battery is 4MJ and max lap energy recovery is 9MJ at the moment.
Maybe you should read the comment I was replying to.
I did read it, the comment is saying to raise the 9MJ limit to 10MJ, you don't need a 10MJ battery to do that, at worst a 5MJ maintains the same ratio.
Just increase allowed charge to 10 MJ or so. We'd get full out quali runs with 0 recharging.
He is saying to increase the ES to 10 MJ, not the harvest limit. The only way to drive a quali lap "full out" without recharging is to have the energy onboard to begin with. Upping the harvest limit would not help one bit.

dialtone
dialtone
139
Joined: 25 Feb 2019, 01:31

Re: Are 2026 F1 regulations broken? How to fix them?

Post

Badger wrote:
12 Feb 2026, 20:43
dialtone wrote:
12 Feb 2026, 20:36
Badger wrote:
12 Feb 2026, 20:35

Maybe you should read the comment I was replying to.
I did read it, the comment is saying to raise the 9MJ limit to 10MJ, you don't need a 10MJ battery to do that, at worst a 5MJ maintains the same ratio.
Just increase allowed charge to 10 MJ or so. We'd get full out quali runs with 0 recharging.
He is saying to increase the ES to 10 MJ, not the harvest limit. The only way to drive a quali lap "full out" without recharging is to have the energy onboard to begin with. Upping the harvest limit would not help one bit.
Right, I think OP just meant it as "people will not lift on purpose to just recharge if you allow them to regen 10MJ, e.g. from burning fuel, and they can use 10MJ in the lap".