2026 Drama: Alleged engine loophole

Post here all non technical related topics about Formula One. This includes race results, discussions, testing analysis etc. TV coverage and other personal questions should be in Off topic chat.
User avatar
Stu
Moderator
Joined: 02 Nov 2019, 10:05
Location: Norfolk, UK

Re: 2026 Drama: Alleged engine loophole

Post

Badger wrote:
26 Feb 2026, 22:12
Frank73 wrote:
26 Feb 2026, 21:43
Stu wrote:
26 Feb 2026, 21:15
=D>

=D> =D> =D> =D>
Yeah but if someone is awarded easy wins in a long row by letting him walk away with a cheat, people will soon stop talking about formula1 and what is more will soon stop watching
:-({|=

Team Total 2025 prize money
Ferrari $277.7m
Mercedes $230.8m
Red Bull $202.9m
McLaren $165.8m
Aston $109.3m
Alpine $99.9m
Haas $91.5m
VCARB $82m
Williams $77.2m
Sauber $63.1m
In what is effectively a 10 (now 11) team franchise how tf can that be right?
Is 2025 prize money based upon 2024 finishing order?
Perspective - Understanding that sometimes the truths we cling to depend greatly on our own point of view.

Frank73
Frank73
0
Joined: 28 Jan 2026, 12:53

Re: 2026 Drama: Alleged engine loophole

Post

Badger wrote:
26 Feb 2026, 22:12
Frank73 wrote:
26 Feb 2026, 21:43
Stu wrote:
26 Feb 2026, 21:15
=D>

=D> =D> =D> =D>
Yeah but if someone is awarded easy wins in a long row by letting him walk away with a cheat, people will soon stop talking about formula1 and what is more will soon stop watching
:-({|=

Team Total 2025 prize money
Ferrari $277.7m
Mercedes $230.8m
Red Bull $202.9m
McLaren $165.8m
Aston $109.3m
Alpine $99.9m
Haas $91.5m
VCARB $82m
Williams $77.2m
Sauber $63.1m
Nearly irrelevant in a budget-constrained formula. Facilities that Mercedes can rely on for being third biggest carmaker in the world (or fourth, or fifth, it does not make any relevant difference) have a much bigger impact.

Badger
Badger
30
Joined: 22 Sep 2025, 17:00

Re: 2026 Drama: Alleged engine loophole

Post

Stu wrote:
26 Feb 2026, 22:40
Badger wrote:
26 Feb 2026, 22:12
Frank73 wrote:
26 Feb 2026, 21:43


Yeah but if someone is awarded easy wins in a long row by letting him walk away with a cheat, people will soon stop talking about formula1 and what is more will soon stop watching
:-({|=

Team Total 2025 prize money
Ferrari $277.7m
Mercedes $230.8m
Red Bull $202.9m
McLaren $165.8m
Aston $109.3m
Alpine $99.9m
Haas $91.5m
VCARB $82m
Williams $77.2m
Sauber $63.1m
In what is effectively a 10 (now 11) team franchise how tf can that be right?
Is 2025 prize money based upon 2024 finishing order?
Nope. Just the absurdity of Ferrari's special payment.

Frank73
Frank73
0
Joined: 28 Jan 2026, 12:53

Re: 2026 Drama: Alleged engine loophole

Post

Badger wrote:
26 Feb 2026, 22:48
Stu wrote:
26 Feb 2026, 22:40
Badger wrote:
26 Feb 2026, 22:12

:-({|=

Team Total 2025 prize money
Ferrari $277.7m
Mercedes $230.8m
Red Bull $202.9m
McLaren $165.8m
Aston $109.3m
Alpine $99.9m
Haas $91.5m
VCARB $82m
Williams $77.2m
Sauber $63.1m
In what is effectively a 10 (now 11) team franchise how tf can that be right?
Is 2025 prize money based upon 2024 finishing order?
Nope. Just the absurdity of Ferrari's special payment.
Maybe but that does not increase Ferrari's winning odds by 1 part in a million. On the contrary, the CR cheat could have been well the by-product of a hugely funded research program on alloys by corporate Mercedes, or even an on-purpose program disguised in mother company the gigantic capital expenditure.

dialtone
dialtone
139
Joined: 25 Feb 2019, 01:31

Re: 2026 Drama: Alleged engine loophole

Post

Badger wrote:
26 Feb 2026, 22:48
Stu wrote:
26 Feb 2026, 22:40
Badger wrote:
26 Feb 2026, 22:12

:-({|=

Team Total 2025 prize money
Ferrari $277.7m
Mercedes $230.8m
Red Bull $202.9m
McLaren $165.8m
Aston $109.3m
Alpine $99.9m
Haas $91.5m
VCARB $82m
Williams $77.2m
Sauber $63.1m
In what is effectively a 10 (now 11) team franchise how tf can that be right?
Is 2025 prize money based upon 2024 finishing order?
Nope. Just the absurdity of Ferrari's special payment.
Ferrari negotiated a better contract with FIA and FOM. A contract that sees Williams and MCL paid for it as well.

Nothing to talk about.

Badger
Badger
30
Joined: 22 Sep 2025, 17:00

Re: 2026 Drama: Alleged engine loophole

Post

Frank73 wrote:
26 Feb 2026, 22:56
Badger wrote:
26 Feb 2026, 22:48
Stu wrote:
26 Feb 2026, 22:40


In what is effectively a 10 (now 11) team franchise how tf can that be right?
Is 2025 prize money based upon 2024 finishing order?
Nope. Just the absurdity of Ferrari's special payment.
Maybe but that does not increase Ferrari's winning odds by 1 part in a million. On the contrary, the CR cheat could have been well the by-product of a hugely funded research program on alloys by corporate Mercedes, or even an on-purpose program disguised in mother company the gigantic capital expenditure.
I think if other teams had the know-how to build an engine to run above 16:1 with the rules as they were written, they would have done so too. I don't hold it against Merc because it's what F1 is about, pushing the limits of the rules. God knows Ferrari has done more questionable things on the engine side and drawn great advantage from it too.

As for the payments, this is the most obvious unfairness in the sport alongside the veto right. Not winning for 17 years + finishing 4th shouldn't entitle you to $110 million more than than the constructor's champions, it's patently absurd. Ferrari is not the victim of this system, it's the trust fund kid who gets paid regardless of how he performs :lol:
Last edited by Badger on 26 Feb 2026, 23:05, edited 1 time in total.

User avatar
dans79
267
Joined: 03 Mar 2013, 19:33
Location: USA

Re: 2026 Drama: Alleged engine loophole

Post

Stu wrote:
26 Feb 2026, 22:40
In what is effectively a 10 (now 11) team franchise how tf can that be right?
Is 2025 prize money based upon 2024 finishing order?
because the payout mechanism is convoluted. Some teams get bonuses because of where they finished in the championship over the last several years.

Read this it explains a lot of it.
https://www.the-race.com/formula-1/f1-2 ... ly-fourth/
202 105 104 9 9 7

dialtone
dialtone
139
Joined: 25 Feb 2019, 01:31

Re: 2026 Drama: Alleged engine loophole

Post

Badger wrote:
Frank73 wrote:
26 Feb 2026, 22:56
Badger wrote:
26 Feb 2026, 22:48
Nope. Just the absurdity of Ferrari's special payment.
Maybe but that does not increase Ferrari's winning odds by 1 part in a million. On the contrary, the CR cheat could have been well the by-product of a hugely funded research program on alloys by corporate Mercedes, or even an on-purpose program disguised in mother company the gigantic capital expenditure.
I think if other teams had the know-how to build an engine to run above 16:1 with the rules as they were written, they would have done so too. I don't hold it against Merc because it's what F1 is about, pushing the limits of the rules. God knows Ferrari has done more questionable things on the engine side, and drawn great advantage from it too.

As for the payments, this is the most obvious unfairness in the sport alongside the veto right. Not winning for 17 years + finishing 4th shouldn't entitle you to $110 million more than than the constructor's champions, it's patently absurd. Ferrari is not the victim of this system, it's the trust fund kid who gets paid regardless of how he performs :lol:
Lmao.

Not even hiding the trolling basically.

Frank73
Frank73
0
Joined: 28 Jan 2026, 12:53

Re: 2026 Drama: Alleged engine loophole

Post

Badger wrote:
26 Feb 2026, 23:04
Frank73 wrote:
26 Feb 2026, 22:56
Badger wrote:
26 Feb 2026, 22:48

Nope. Just the absurdity of Ferrari's special payment.
Maybe but that does not increase Ferrari's winning odds by 1 part in a million. On the contrary, the CR cheat could have been well the by-product of a hugely funded research program on alloys by corporate Mercedes, or even an on-purpose program disguised in mother company the gigantic capital expenditure.
I think if other teams had the know-how to build an engine to run above 16:1 with the rules as they were written, they would have done so too. I don't hold it against Merc because it's what F1 is about, pushing the limits of the rules. God knows Ferrari has done more questionable things on the engine side and drawn great advantage from it too.

As for the payments, this is the most obvious unfairness in the sport alongside the veto right. Not winning for 17 years + finishing 4th shouldn't entitle you to $110 million more than than the constructor's champions, it's patently absurd. Ferrari is not the victim of this system, it's the trust fund kid who gets paid regardless of how he performs :lol:
Than McLaren should have been awarded a pizza margerita (not pepperoni, too expensive) from 2015 to 2022.

Frank73
Frank73
0
Joined: 28 Jan 2026, 12:53

Re: 2026 Drama: Alleged engine loophole

Post

Badger wrote:
26 Feb 2026, 23:04
Frank73 wrote:
26 Feb 2026, 22:56
Badger wrote:
26 Feb 2026, 22:48

Nope. Just the absurdity of Ferrari's special payment.
Maybe but that does not increase Ferrari's winning odds by 1 part in a million. On the contrary, the CR cheat could have been well the by-product of a hugely funded research program on alloys by corporate Mercedes, or even an on-purpose program disguised in mother company the gigantic capital expenditure.
God knows Ferrari has done more questionable things on the engine side and drawn great advantage from it too.
It is instead well known that Mercedes had been hugely cheating at least from 2014 to 2017 with its super-chips frier MacMerc oil burning engine - representing 95% of merit of those four titles in a row - that was completely illegal cause via alleged oil leak was making additives enter the combustion chambers, which has always been prohibited, and that Fia pretended not to suspect about until everyone had it. Then they banned the trick, but only after Mercedes alone could introduce (at Monza gp) the latest version with all improvements (could fry also big fishes).

upsidedowntoast
upsidedowntoast
0
Joined: 10 Feb 2026, 20:38

Re: 2026 Drama: Alleged engine loophole

Post

Frank73 wrote:
26 Feb 2026, 23:26
Badger wrote:
26 Feb 2026, 23:04
Frank73 wrote:
26 Feb 2026, 22:56


Maybe but that does not increase Ferrari's winning odds by 1 part in a million. On the contrary, the CR cheat could have been well the by-product of a hugely funded research program on alloys by corporate Mercedes, or even an on-purpose program disguised in mother company the gigantic capital expenditure.
God knows Ferrari has done more questionable things on the engine side and drawn great advantage from it too.
It is instead well known that Mercedes had been hugely cheating at least from 2014 to 2017 with its super-chips frier MacMerc oil burning engine - representing 95% of merit of those four titles in a row - that was completely illegal cause via alleged oil leak was making additives enter the combustion chambers, which has always been prohibited, and that Fia pretended not to suspect about until everyone had it. Then they banned the trick, but only after Mercedes alone could introduce (at Monza gp) the latest version with all improvements (could fry also big fishes).
"When everyone else does something, they are corrupt FIA-buying cheaters; when my team does it, they are true engineering genuises."

-- Sun Tzu

Frank73
Frank73
0
Joined: 28 Jan 2026, 12:53

Re: 2026 Drama: Alleged engine loophole

Post

upsidedowntoast wrote:
26 Feb 2026, 23:33
Frank73 wrote:
26 Feb 2026, 23:26
Badger wrote:
26 Feb 2026, 23:04

God knows Ferrari has done more questionable things on the engine side and drawn great advantage from it too.
It is instead well known that Mercedes had been hugely cheating at least from 2014 to 2017 with its super-chips frier MacMerc oil burning engine - representing 95% of merit of those four titles in a row - that was completely illegal cause via alleged oil leak was making additives enter the combustion chambers, which has always been prohibited, and that Fia pretended not to suspect about until everyone had it. Then they banned the trick, but only after Mercedes alone could introduce (at Monza gp) the latest version with all improvements (could fry also big fishes).
"When everyone else does something, they are corrupt FIA-buying cheaters; when my team does it, they are true engineering genuises."

-- Sun Tzu
All the teams have tried questionable shortcuts in f1 history, but some have been thoroughly investigated and then stopped, others have been covered for.

SB15
SB15
7
Joined: 15 Feb 2025, 22:47

Re: 2026 Drama: Alleged engine loophole

Post

dia6olo wrote:
26 Feb 2026, 17:06
SB15 wrote:
26 Feb 2026, 15:33
basti313 wrote:
26 Feb 2026, 13:25

Sounds good. A measurement when hot is a fair solution, as this is the only number that is relevant for the efficiency/power. Like this any expansion tricks are useless.
Still if the numbers in this article are true, there will be a big advantage for Merc through this season. With the issue for them, that they need to dial back on CR middle of this season.
I mean Mercedes still said they're confident with the engines passing the test regardless, so the others manufactuers can try whatever circumstance against Mercedes, it'll still be the same result.
Every manufacturer always says something along the lines of it won't affect us. When there's a rule that is specifically aimed at them it pretty much always does affect them.
I doubt that since they would've known that these "tests" would've taken place ahead of time.

User avatar
Stu
Moderator
Joined: 02 Nov 2019, 10:05
Location: Norfolk, UK

Re: 2026 Drama: Alleged engine loophole

Post

dans79 wrote:
26 Feb 2026, 23:05
Stu wrote:
26 Feb 2026, 22:40
In what is effectively a 10 (now 11) team franchise how tf can that be right?
Is 2025 prize money based upon 2024 finishing order?
because the payout mechanism is convoluted. Some teams get bonuses because of where they finished in the championship over the last several years.

Read this it explains a lot of it.
https://www.the-race.com/formula-1/f1-2 ... ly-fourth/
That helps the numbers to make sense, a real shame that the original poster didn’t include sources for the information posted. I’m disappointed in myself for taking the bait.
Thank you @dans79, worthy of an upvote.
Perspective - Understanding that sometimes the truths we cling to depend greatly on our own point of view.

kptaylor
kptaylor
0
Joined: 01 Feb 2012, 22:11
Location: Cluj-Napoca, RO

Re: 2026 Drama: Alleged engine loophole

Post

Naive question, apologies. Even if the FIA make the directive on the engines with an Aug 2026 effective date, can other constructors still file a complaint that the others' engines are illegal and force the issue? (And find out a bit more on how it might be accomplished...)