upsidedowntoast wrote: ↑27 Feb 2026, 17:09
Putting in my 2c as an outsider without emotional attachment to either Honda or AMR, this project seemed doomed for failure in a way that's everyone's fault.
- Honda chose to leave right when they were becoming successful with Red Bull, and then jumped back in later than everyone else.
- It's still not clear how much personnel from the successful Honda engine was lost to RBPT or the other PU manufacturers in the meantime.
- Then Newey comes, late.
- Then Newey forces a redesign, robbing them of even more time they didn't have.
- For some reason, such as cultural communication issues or too much Newey-worship, no one pushes back on these demands.
- On top of that Aston is trying to make their own brand new gearbox for the first time amongst other things, and it looks like they don't have good integration testing processes for all those things yet.
The same exact problem with McHonda back in the day: Honda was forced to join a year before they were ready, with unreasonable specs. I estimate that between the late recommitment and Newey's demands they were robbed of even more time.
If you want to be a works team, you have to work with your PU manufacturer, not treat them as a subcontractor. I can't imagine the Ferrari or Mercedes chassis people making such demands of their engine people. They should have done what Cadillac is doing -- stick with their known PU until they are sure they can manufacture a gearbox and everything themselves, and make their own engine last. Were they still using a Mercedes engine, Newey would have had no choice but to design around it.