f1316 wrote: ↑11 Mar 2026, 20:59
I have a couple of provocative thoughts about these new cars/races:
(1) a lot of complaints about how awful the qualifying session in Melbourne was because of the LICO and super clipping. I would love to see what the average fan would feel about that session if it had been close. If it’s exciting and the drivers have to make the best use of the tools available to them - even if they involve some “un-F1” elements - how much do we really care? I 100% think this shouldn’t be the formula that F1 has come up with, both is it more interesting in a sporting spectacle than, say, my favourite F1 season in 2004 when they had pretty much “perfect” F1 cars and Michael dominated?
(2) people keep saying that we need graphics and things to tell us what’s going on and how much charge everyone has. I completely disagree. I think F1 was better before we knew exactly how everything was playing out and there was a mystery - what is Prost managing? What fuel strategy is everyone on? I think it keeps it intriguing if you know what’s happening but not always why.
I’m sure people will vehemently disagree but wanted to give my two cents.
1. I think people would still hate the super clipping. Energy starvation is the last thing I want in F1. That said, I thought boost/overtake mode was fun. So I think that what they *should have* done is, for qualifying or a regular lap, no energy starvation at all; bump up fuel flow or something to make the ICE stronger. BUT: keep boost/overtake mode, only limit how much you can store and charge for that -- so you *only* have energy starvation for boost/overtake mode. So there will still be some element of battery management and strategic thinking, but not for qualifying or most of the race.
2. Partial disagree, some graphics are nice. The mystery would sadly lead to frustration from viewers and unfair accusations against drivers. Graphics help separate what's going on with the car vs. the team vs. the driver. Plus they're helpful for newcomers to the sport and people with vision disabilities. That said I suppose with how digital broadcasting is now it shouldn't be *that* hard to let viewers toggle which stats they do or don't want to see onscreen: it would be a fun interactive thing for people who are paying to watch, and maybe they could add this customization in as an extra premium feature for the hardcore fans.