Any motorsport racing has never being about overtaking, let alone back and forth type of racing, which is utter nonsense itself. The whole point of qualifying is and has always been to put fastest cars/drivers ahead of the slower ones so they wouldn't be interfering with them, allowing fastest cars to get another advantage and finish the race the quickest which is the point of racing. Not finish the race by overtaking the most ammount of cars. Overtaking can occur only when a faster car-driver finds himself behind the slower combo, which in itself isDDopey wrote: ↑29 Mar 2026, 10:07So this is what I do not understand. Most of the F1 races were not about overtakes. So what have you been watching all this time? Are you a new viewer or …. I dont get this. If you didn’t find the F1 interesting, why watch ? I enjoyed the F1 without yoyo racing, cars pushing and saving depending on the stage in race. Seeing if their faster rounds made sense, and so on. All the dynamic, the build up to an overtake etc.Emag wrote: ↑29 Mar 2026, 09:55You need to pull some crazy mental gymnastics to call Suzuka one of the best races of 2025. It was literally more boring than Monaco to watch. There was nothing happening in it 90% of the time.
And I don't know for you, but I personally definitely knew who the winner would be. It should have been one of the McLaren drivers if McLaren actually split strategies and tried to win the race like a normal team. Since McLaren did not do that, Max had it in the bag as you couldn't overtake for sh*t at Suzuka with the cars last year. It was something like 15 overtakes the whole race after lap 1. Horrible.
But any of those seasons would be better with easier overtakes. Easier overtakes are a plus.AR3-GP wrote: ↑29 Mar 2026, 10:09What I don't follow in these discussions is that 2021 was one of the best seasons of all time, yet it is said that overtaking was impossible with those cars. How can this be? What is showing is that the core element of what makes F1 interesting is not the number of overtakes. It's something else. Chasing overtaking specifically is a band-aid imo.
I am sorry, but what buildup to an overtake did you witness in Suzuka last year?DDopey wrote: ↑29 Mar 2026, 10:07So this is what I do not understand. Most of the F1 races were not about overtakes. So what have you been watching all this time? Are you a new viewer or …. I dont get this. If you didn’t find the F1 interesting, why watch ? I enjoyed the F1 without yoyo racing, cars pushing and saving depending on the stage in race. Seeing if their faster rounds made sense, and so on. All the dynamic, the build up to an overtake etc.Emag wrote: ↑29 Mar 2026, 09:55You need to pull some crazy mental gymnastics to call Suzuka one of the best races of 2025. It was literally more boring than Monaco to watch. There was nothing happening in it 90% of the time.
And I don't know for you, but I personally definitely knew who the winner would be. It should have been one of the McLaren drivers if McLaren actually split strategies and tried to win the race like a normal team. Since McLaren did not do that, Max had it in the bag as you couldn't overtake for sh*t at Suzuka with the cars last year. It was something like 15 overtakes the whole race after lap 1. Horrible.
Depends on what you judge it on. If you judge it purely from an on-track battle perspective, 2021 was a very bad season. From other perspectives it's one of the best because you had two amazing drivers who pushed their respective machinery to the limit and the title battle went down to the wire because of it. There was something awesome in watching Lewis and Max pull 30-40 seconds on their teammates like it was nothing.AR3-GP wrote: ↑29 Mar 2026, 10:09What I don't follow in these discussions is that 2021 was one of the best seasons of all time, yet it is said that overtaking was impossible with those cars. How can this be? What it shows is that the core element of what makes F1 interesting is not the number of overtakes. It's something deeper, the tension and the competitors. Tripling the number of overtakes doesn't automatically make things better.
but that's the problem with the crowd that F1 wants to sell to now. They are not interested in following longer plots. They want to be able to come and go without context, without knowledge of the rivalries, the teams, the history. That is who the current concept of 500 overtakes favors.
No, it would be worse. Easier overtakes is a negative. Not saying that complete improbability of overtaking is good either. But Alonso keeping Hamilton behind for multiple laps in a car 1,5s slower was a great thing, a great show and one of the highlights of the year (won the FIA award by the way as far as I recall). Lewis did finally got through but it was anything but easy.FittingMechanics wrote: ↑29 Mar 2026, 10:12But any of those seasons would be better with easier overtakes. Easier overtakes are a plus.AR3-GP wrote: ↑29 Mar 2026, 10:09What I don't follow in these discussions is that 2021 was one of the best seasons of all time, yet it is said that overtaking was impossible with those cars. How can this be? What is showing is that the core element of what makes F1 interesting is not the number of overtakes. It's something else. Chasing overtaking specifically is a band-aid imo.
Maybe to you, a very dedicated fan that watches all the races, engages in forum discussion and knows the intricacies. To the average fan/watcher it is not.avantman wrote: ↑29 Mar 2026, 10:28No, it would be worse. Easier overtakes is a negative. Not saying that complete improbability of overtaking is good either. But Alonso keeping Hamilton behind for multiple laps in a car 1,5s slower was a great thing, a great show and one of the highlights of the year (won the FIA award by the way as far as I recall). Lewis did finally got through but it was anything but easy.FittingMechanics wrote: ↑29 Mar 2026, 10:12But any of those seasons would be better with easier overtakes. Easier overtakes are a plus.AR3-GP wrote: ↑29 Mar 2026, 10:09What I don't follow in these discussions is that 2021 was one of the best seasons of all time, yet it is said that overtaking was impossible with those cars. How can this be? What is showing is that the core element of what makes F1 interesting is not the number of overtakes. It's something else. Chasing overtaking specifically is a band-aid imo.
The easier overtaking is, the less meaningful and valuable each of those becomes.
Not many probably know or remember but Suzuka ‘25 was one of those rare races of modern Pirelli era where drivers could actually push as hard as they can for the whole race, especially on the 2nd stint on hard, there was almost no (or very little) tire management involved. Which makes mistakes probable. One tiny mistake from the leader and McLaren would’ve gotten him.FittingMechanics wrote: ↑29 Mar 2026, 10:33Maybe to you, a very dedicated fan that watches all the races, engages in forum discussion and knows the intricacies. To the average fan/watcher it is not.avantman wrote: ↑29 Mar 2026, 10:28No, it would be worse. Easier overtakes is a negative. Not saying that complete improbability of overtaking is good either. But Alonso keeping Hamilton behind for multiple laps in a car 1,5s slower was a great thing, a great show and one of the highlights of the year (won the FIA award by the way as far as I recall). Lewis did finally got through but it was anything but easy.FittingMechanics wrote: ↑29 Mar 2026, 10:12
But any of those seasons would be better with easier overtakes. Easier overtakes are a plus.
The easier overtaking is, the less meaningful and valuable each of those becomes.
Would the same fight for most of the race be notable or even noticed if it happened further down the grid? We had Verstallen stuck behind Gasly for most of the race today, there was no yoyoing at all.
What was interesting in McLaren following Verstappen in Japan 2025? In 2026 rules they would have many attempts and action, much more wheel to wheel action and excitement.
Yes, being a huge JB fan in the past, both as a driver and particularly commentator, I am especially disappointed with him.. sold his soul completely. Never expected anything better from talking heads like Chandhok, Crofty, Brundle or Davidson, who are just fulfilling their contracts….but not Jenson.