McLaren with Honda engines in 2014

Post here all non technical related topics about Formula One. This includes race results, discussions, testing analysis etc. TV coverage and other personal questions should be in Off topic chat.
Richard
Richard
Moderator
Joined: 15 Apr 2009, 14:41
Location: UK

Re: McLaren with Honda engines in 2014

Post

I agree that I expect McL to have their own engines in 2022.

The steps to get their are tricky because they would be crazy to drop down the grid simply to massage their ego with a McLaren badge on the engine block. It would have to be as competitive as possible when launched in their car. I could imagine FI and Virgin running Ricardo engines for a year or two before it became a McLaren engine in a McLaren car.

OverSquare
OverSquare
0
Joined: 17 Jun 2012, 01:07

Re: McLaren with Honda engines in 2014

Post

Overlaying McLaren Cars longer term strategy, a McLaren engine seems logical, especially when it is developed to th3 2014 rules.
Ron Dennis has openly stated that his vision for McLaren cars is rival Ferrari. That menas creating an english iconic brand that will last the next 100years. To do that McLaren needs to become completley self sufficient.
Sure selling 10,000 MP4/12c's a year is not going to do it, but he has also stated that McLaren will be introdcing bread and butter sports cars as well. With that I assume he means sports cars in the GBP50,000 region. i.e. cash cows.
This thread is a bit old, but the topic is so relevant - BUMP!

"Overlaying" Me thinks you've hit the proverbial nail on the head for a number of reasons. This is long term strategy so it's interesting to speculate on how McLaren will achieve that goal. I think your assertion, fact, that McLaren is going to be more than a one-car-company pretty much ameliorates (pari parsu) arguments made by others here that McLaren will not be able to afford the program. The question then becomes at what stage does McLaren make this step?

I'm not an mechanical engineer so I can't speak to the costing structure and technical hurdles of developing a 21st century F1 engine, but knowing what I do about program management in high technology world, the learning curve is very steep indeed. In F1 where slight hp/torque advantages return sub-second/lap gains seems to be where the 'experience' and 'data' arguments begin to make sense particularly when one defines the relevant question as not about 'building' an engine but building a 'winning engine'. I will note that that 2014 engine specs seem relatively attainable with 15,000 rmp limit - I know I'm being a little pollyannish given that, as others have noted, it is now about the whole package (blower, kers, etc.).
This is clearly non-trivial and filled with risk.

So this joint development with Ricardo makes sense (is Ron playing the Japanese incremental development game here?). The question in my mind is how does Ron Dennis merge the development effort of Ricardo with McLaren's goal of being self-sufficient? How long will McLaren be willing to be a mid-pack performer until it gets the technology right? If I were the boss, would I want to be out of the gate in 2014 with the rest of the pack with my own engine or do I wait till the technology is more developed by others before jumping in whilst waiting for my retail revenue stream to match the R&D cost of this package? Does self-sufficient mean McLaren only or does it include joint branded type effort with Ricardo?

More speculation appreciated?
Last edited by Steven on 20 Jun 2012, 23:19, edited 1 time in total.
Reason: Fix quotes

elmerfud
elmerfud
0
Joined: 04 Feb 2008, 12:46
Location: Dandenong

Re: McLaren with Honda engines in 2014

Post

On page 4 the off topic chat spoke off a nissan sourced design in the mp2-12, last year i applied for a job at cosworth in northampton and they were milling the block and heads for that motor on a mori seiki palletized horizontal machining centre and i could swear that motor is a copy off the oldsmobile aurora v8.

User avatar
adrianjordan
24
Joined: 28 Feb 2010, 11:34
Location: West Yorkshire, England

Re: McLaren with Honda engines in 2014

Post

OverSquare wrote:[Overlaying McLaren Cars longer term strategy, a McLaren engine seems logical, especially when it is developed to th3 2014 rules.
Ron Dennis has openly stated that his vision for McLaren cars is rival Ferrari. That menas creating an english iconic brand that will last the next 100years. To do that McLaren needs to become completley self sufficient.
Sure selling 10,000 MP4/12c's a year is not going to do it, but he has also stated that McLaren will be introdcing bread and butter sports cars as well. With that I assume he means sports cars in the GBP50,000 region. i.e. cash cows.
This thread is a bit old, but the topic is so relevant - BUMP!

"Overlaying" Me thinks you've hit the proverbial nail on the head for a number of reasons. This is long term strategy so it's interesting to speculate on how McLaren will achieve that goal. I think your assertion, fact, that McLaren is going to be more than a one-car-company pretty much ameliorates (pari parsu) arguments made by others here that McLaren will not be able to afford the program. The question then becomes at what stage does McLaren make this step?

I'm not an mechanical engineer so I can't speak to the costing structure and technical hurdles of developing a 21st century F1 engine, but knowing what I do about program management in high technology world, the learning curve is very steep indeed. In F1 where slight hp/torque advantages return sub-second/lap gains seems to be where the 'experience' and 'data' arguments begin to make sense particularly when one defines the relevant question as not about 'building' an engine but building a 'winning engine'. I will note that that 2014 engine specs seem relatively attainable with 15,000 rmp limit - I know I'm being a little pollyannish given that, as others have noted, it is now about the whole package (blower, kers, etc.).
This is clearly non-trivial and filled with risk.

So this joint development with Ricardo makes sense (is Ron playing the Japanese incremental development game here?). The question in my mind is how does Ron Dennis merge the development effort of Ricardo with McLaren's goal of being self-sufficient? How long will McLaren be willing to be a mid-pack performer until it gets the technology right? If I were the boss, would I want to be out of the gate in 2014 with the rest of the pack with my own engine or do I wait till the technology is more developed by others before jumping in whilst waiting for my retail revenue stream to match the R&D cost of this package? Does self-sufficient mean McLaren only or does it include joint branded type effort with Ricardo?

More speculation appreciated?[/quote]

Could it be that McLaren's long term plan would involve actually buying into Ricardo (in the same way that Merc bought into Ilmor) and eventually taking them over completely?
Last edited by Steven on 20 Jun 2012, 23:19, edited 1 time in total.
Reason: Fix quotes
Favourite driver: Lando Norris
Favourite team: McLaren

Turned down the chance to meet Vettel at Silverstone in 2007. He was a test driver at the time and I didn't think it was worth queuing!! 🤦🏻‍♂️

OverSquare
OverSquare
0
Joined: 17 Jun 2012, 01:07

Re: McLaren with Honda engines in 2014

Post

adrianjordan wrote:Could it be that McLaren's long term plan would involve actually buying into Ricardo (in the same way that Merc bought into Ilmor) and eventually taking them over completely?
I consider this too. Seems that much would be compromised in Ricardo's consulting biz model.

I suppose my questions are a bit off from thread topic - no intent to hijack...
Last edited by mx_tifoso on 21 Jun 2012, 05:41, edited 1 time in total.
Reason: fixed quote

Nando
Nando
2
Joined: 10 Mar 2012, 02:30

Re: McLaren with Honda engines in 2014

Post

BMW should comeback, develop an engine specifically for Mclaren and go from there.

Last time they partnered, amazing things happened.
"Il Phenomeno" - The one they fear the most!

"2% of the world's population own 50% of the world's wealth."

User avatar
JohnsonsEvilTwin
0
Joined: 29 Jan 2010, 11:51
Location: SU 419113

Re: McLaren with Honda engines in 2014

Post

Nando wrote:BMW should comeback, develop an engine specifically for Mclaren and go from there.

Last time they partnered, amazing things happened.

BMW will never comeback until they have a reason to do so. That reason is whether they can market technology garnered from F1. F1 is a white elephant, and most manufacturers don't need it.
Toyota did Le mans on around 30 million, Almost a tenth of what they spent on F1 annually.

Personally I think all the manufacturers are looking at Sportscars for innovation and competition. McLaren-BMW there?
Possible. But not F1 IMO.
More could have been done.
David Purley

RacingManiac
RacingManiac
9
Joined: 22 Nov 2004, 02:29

Re: McLaren with Honda engines in 2014

Post

I don't think its entirely that rare for people to utilize specialists like Ricardo or FEV, or AVL or something to do a lot of R&D and design work. The fact of the matter is the IP is owned by the people who paid for the work. It is often time more economically feasible to use an outside firm and paid them for their work, than hiring your own engine specialists and form your own group. Especially in the stage when you are starting up. And even if you are not a fresh starter like McLaren you can still use outside help. AFAIK a lot of the new Chrysler/Fiat engines' base design were done outside of their own engineering group. Then transferred into the company to finish.

Also, works like these, all the data, design work and knowledge gained from the process are completely shared with the people who paid for the work. So its much easier to build future project around that. Its very different from when you just buy engine from someone like Honda or BMW, or Mercedes. As they are not obligated to give you anything aside from whats needed to operate the engine.