
I think so.elf341 wrote:Are these W03-C sidepods new?
Or perhaps you are mistaken?skgoa wrote:Everyone who has used the word "coanda" to describe this exhaust layout should stop posting about aerodynamics. You guys are embarassing yourselves.This exhaust doesn't use the coanda effect, as should be obvious, since there is NO CONTINUOUS BODYWORK leading to the diffusor gap. Thus there is no surface for the coanda effect to happen. Well, actually the coanda effect makes air go around the sidepods ("under" the exhaust stream) and to the top of the diffusor but that has nothing to do with the exhaust itself.)
Source: http://www.autosport.com/news/report.php/id/102447Ross Brawn wrote:"We weren't understanding the tyres and concluded that the most effective thing we could do, rather than go straight to a Coanda-system, was to understand the tyres, to get them a bit more under control,"
The Coanda effect is employed at various stages of the exhaust setup. The actual exhaust tailpipe on the Mclaren points outwards to the maximum the regulations allow and are concealed within the housing that forms the rear of the sidepod. The Coanda effect begins inside the sidepod using the inner wall of the outer edge of the housing to bounce the gases back inboard of the rear wheels.elf341 wrote:Or perhaps you are mistaken?skgoa wrote:Everyone who has used the word "coanda" to describe this exhaust layout should stop posting about aerodynamics. You guys are embarassing yourselves.This exhaust doesn't use the coanda effect, as should be obvious, since there is NO CONTINUOUS BODYWORK leading to the diffusor gap. Thus there is no surface for the coanda effect to happen. Well, actually the coanda effect makes air go around the sidepods ("under" the exhaust stream) and to the top of the diffusor but that has nothing to do with the exhaust itself.)
Source: http://www.autosport.com/news/report.php/id/102447Ross Brawn wrote:"We weren't understanding the tyres and concluded that the most effective thing we could do, rather than go straight to a Coanda-system, was to understand the tyres, to get them a bit more under control,"
It looks different because they are grafting it onto a different shaped car. The philisophy is common with those teams though. I can't see this being the magic bullet for mercedes though, the area above the diffuser is no tidier than the Force India and they've got a head start with the technology.clipsy1H wrote:i'm not home now but can someone post here a photo with McLaren Redull and Sauber exhausts in comparison with w03?
for me w03 exhaust looks little different
What? The exhaust exit is continued by 2 side "walls" which are angled towards the diffuser. This is most certainly a coanda effect. The difference with red bull and sauber is a slightly different approach towards the downwash effect. Both approaches have their advantages: red bull effectively seperates the normal airflow from the exhausts, while with the mclaren approach the downwash effect is more powerfull. But both uses the coanda effect.skgoa wrote:Everyone who has used the word "coanda" to describe this exhaust layout should stop posting about aerodynamics. You guys are embarassing yourselves.This exhaust doesn't use the coanda effect, as should be obvious, since there is NO CONTINUOUS BODYWORK leading to the diffusor gap. Thus there is no surface for the coanda effect to happen. Well, actually the coanda effect makes air go around the sidepods ("under" the exhaust stream) and to the top of the diffusor but that has nothing to do with the exhaust itself.)
edit: To make this abundantly clear, look at the Sauber and Red Bull exhausts. The have exhaust "ramps" that the exhaust stream stays attached to due to the coanda effect.
It's moments like this where I wish ever post containing "venturi", "coanda" or "fluidic switch" would require mod approval...
But it's all realtive, isn't it? The Mercedes is already generally faster than the Force India without this exhaust, so they're obviously stronger in other areas. The Force India did get stronger when they introduced this style of exhaust, so it's fair to assume that the Merc will benefit from it also.Coefficient wrote:It looks different because they are grafting it onto a different shaped car. The philisophy is common with those teams though. I can't see this being the magic bullet for mercedes though, the area above the diffuser is no tidier than the Force India and they've got a head start with the technology.clipsy1H wrote:i'm not home now but can someone post here a photo with McLaren Redull and Sauber exhausts in comparison with w03?
for me w03 exhaust looks little different