donskar wrote:To paraphrase Phil Hill, MS was a great driver, but he was not a good driver -- a bit too ruthless for my taste. His records are unlikely to ever be broken. He played a very large part in bringing Ferrari back to life. He was supreme leader and team-builder. I love him, but I wish he'd been a little more the gentleman on track.
I am very happy for him and his family that he is able to walk away unbroken and unscarred.
I tend to agree that Schumacher was ruthless, but he wasn't more ruthless than many other drivers have proven to be in situations where they have been under pressure. Actually, I think Schumacher wasn't more ruthless than a driver needs to be in order to achieve success. The big difference between Schumacher and all other drivers is that he has been fighting for the championships almost every year. As much as 10 times he either won the title or lost it in the final race of the season. I think everyone would agree that his collision with Villeneuve in 1997 doesn't look good. But if you put every driver on the grid in the same situation, leading the championship by 1 point and leading the final race, and then being attacked in a somewhat unexpected way, I am sure you would see a lot of crazy maneuvers.
It is some times a thin line between being clever and exploiting every possibility to gain an advantage, and being unsporting. And in some situations one can accuse Schumacher of having crossed this line. But the same could be said about drivers like Prost, Senna, Alonso and Hamilton, just to mention a few. They always try to benefit from any situation, especially when there is a lot at stake, and some times they make a bad judgement.
Anyway, I geuss it doesn't make a big difference if Schumacher quit now or after next season. He seems to be in a team that isn't capable of making a competitive car anyway.