A crisis meeting in the cards?

Post here all non technical related topics about Formula One. This includes race results, discussions, testing analysis etc. TV coverage and other personal questions should be in Off topic chat.
xpensive
xpensive
214
Joined: 22 Nov 2008, 18:06
Location: Somewhere in Scandinavia

Re: A crisis meeting in the cards?

Post

bhallg2k wrote:The four-cylinder engines would have been limited to 12,000 RPM. Not that it matters, because it's the turbo that muffles the exhaust note.
It would matter very little as the 2014 V6s hardly rev much above 12 kRpm anyway.
"I spent most of my money on wine and women...I wasted the rest"

bhall
bhall
244
Joined: 28 Feb 2006, 21:26

Re: A crisis meeting in the cards?

Post

xpensive wrote:
bhallg2k wrote:The four-cylinder engines would have been limited to 12,000 RPM. Not that it matters, because it's the turbo that muffles the exhaust note.
It would matter very little as the 2014 V6s hardly rev much above 12 kRpm anyway.
Yeah, so much torque.

CHT
CHT
-6
Joined: 14 Apr 2008, 05:24

Re: A crisis meeting in the cards?

Post

Spoken to a couple of friends who have attended the race at Melbourne and the feedback I got was pretty bad. And we sort of agree that formula one "green" effort would have been more meaningful if they would have to push technology to make a fuel efficient V8 engine rather than pushing team to make a small and costly green engine. Reason being is that on paper the current power train might seems greener than V8, but if you factor in the resources and carbon footprint that goes into making and perfecting the KERS system, and its limited lifespan and high cost of replacement, F1 might actually be moving backward in their green effort.

Ultimately building a fuel efficient small engine sports car is not going to wow the world as mass market cars are already doing it for years. On the other hand the ability to build a fuel efficient V8 engine will go a long way in its application to the real world sports car industry.

User avatar
Sebp
15
Joined: 09 Mar 2010, 22:52
Location: Surrounded

Re: A crisis meeting in the cards?

Post

F1 for me is a sport and not so much a product. The current development could have very positive results for this, my favourite sport.

Here is how it may shape out:
Less engine noise => disgruntled (mainly neanderthal) fans => less attention => less corporate interest => less sponsorship money => smaller budgets => better, more clever engineering and management of money => revival of the garagistes

There will always be those who continue racing at the highest possible level. Whatever that may be at the time.

Btw I think the whole of this discussion somehow distracts from the fact that there's still this stupid double points business dangling over our heads.
No smartphone was involved in creating this message.

xpensive
xpensive
214
Joined: 22 Nov 2008, 18:06
Location: Somewhere in Scandinavia

Re: A crisis meeting in the cards?

Post

bhallg2k wrote:
xpensive wrote:
bhallg2k wrote:The four-cylinder engines would have been limited to 12,000 RPM. Not that it matters, because it's the turbo that muffles the exhaust note.
It would matter very little as the 2014 V6s hardly rev much above 12 kRpm anyway.
Yeah, so much torque.
Not at 12 000 Rpm, see that's power, torque is what happens between 9 000 and 11 000. Hope I got this right now? #-o
"I spent most of my money on wine and women...I wasted the rest"

User avatar
iotar__
7
Joined: 28 Sep 2012, 12:31

Re: A crisis meeting in the cards?

Post

Sebp wrote:F1 for me is a sport and not so much a product. The current development could have very positive results for this, my favourite sport.

Here is how it may shape out:
Less engine noise => disgruntled (mainly neanderthal) fans => less attention => less corporate interest => less sponsorship money => smaller budgets => better, more clever engineering and management of money => revival of the garagistes

There will always be those who continue racing at the highest possible level. Whatever that may be at the time.

Btw I think the whole of this discussion somehow distracts from the fact that there's still this stupid double points business dangling over our heads.
Less corporate interest? Come on you want to reverse world's development direction with less noise and less fan friendly engines, who's going to pay your favourite drivers and engineers lost of money then?
Who do you think owns F1 or can afford 40 million bribes, Ecclestone and his friends from sandbox or "the private equity firm" CVC. Same for anyone who's willing to buy it now. Merc, Renault, Red Bull, Lotus guys, Mallya/Sahara, Fernandes and Ferrari (Fiat) are big corporations too. I don't know which part is current/future but from here, http://www.pitpass.com/46404/CVC-to-los ... d-in-float
The board will consist of at least 16 people. Alongside Ecclestone, there will be two others who are involved with the daily running of F1. They are the sport's 44 year-old Chief Financial Officer (CFO) Duncan Llowarch, who was appointed in 2002, and its 43 year-old Chief Legal Officer (CLO) Sacha Woodward-Hill who was appointed in 2000. They each own stakes of around 1% in Delta Topco.
There will also be five independent non-executive directors including F1's chairman Peter Brabeck-Letmathe. He is the chairman of Nestle and will get a 0.2% stake in F1 to add to the 0.3% he already owned. The other non-execs include Jean-Marc Huet, chief financial officer of Unilever, Martin Sorrell who is boss of advertising company WPP, and two Singaporeans. They are Liew Mun Leong, chief executive of real estate company CapitaLand, and Kwa Chong Seng, independent deputy chairman of wealth fund Temasek. [...] The final members of the F1 board are connected to CVC [...]

Vettel Maggot
Vettel Maggot
4
Joined: 28 Jan 2014, 08:30

Re: A crisis meeting in the cards?

Post

Vettel the 'neanderthal' has come out and said that he thinks the new engines sound 'shite.'
"It's shite," he said. "That's my opinion and I think for the fans as well. I think Formula One has to be spectacular and the sound is one of the most important things.

"When I was a small child, I don't remember much, but I remember when I was six years old and we went to see the cars live during free practice, the one thing I remember was the sound. How loud they were, to feel the cars through the ground and the whole ground was vibrating. It's a shame you don't have that."

Read more at http://en.espnf1.com/redbull/motorsport ... vxY0Wzh.99

beelsebob
beelsebob
85
Joined: 23 Mar 2011, 15:49
Location: Cupertino, California

Re: A crisis meeting in the cards?

Post

Vettel Maggot wrote:Vettel the 'neanderthal' has come out and said that he thinks the new engines sound 'shite.'
"It's shite," he said. "That's my opinion and I think for the fans as well. I think Formula One has to be spectacular and the sound is one of the most important things.

"When I was a small child, I don't remember much, but I remember when I was six years old and we went to see the cars live during free practice, the one thing I remember was the sound. How loud they were, to feel the cars through the ground and the whole ground was vibrating. It's a shame you don't have that."

Read more at http://en.espnf1.com/redbull/motorsport ... vxY0Wzh.99
Well of course he has – he's RedBull's mouth piece, and it's in their interests to make sure that the old formula comes back.

Vettel Maggot
Vettel Maggot
4
Joined: 28 Jan 2014, 08:30

Re: A crisis meeting in the cards?

Post

Vettel Maggot wrote:Vettel the 'neanderthal' has come out and said that he thinks the new engines sound 'shite.'
"It's shite," he said. "That's my opinion and I think for the fans as well. I think Formula One has to be spectacular and the sound is one of the most important things.

"When I was a small child, I don't remember much, but I remember when I was six years old and we went to see the cars live during free practice, the one thing I remember was the sound. How loud they were, to feel the cars through the ground and the whole ground was vibrating. It's a shame you don't have that."

Read more at http://en.espnf1.com/redbull/motorsport ... vxY0Wzh.99
Not sure why I got a warning for this post from flyboy but what I was pointing out was its silly to call people who do not share the same view as others 'Neanderthals'

Vettel has his opinion and good luck to him as do others. No need for name calling.

Vettel Maggot
Vettel Maggot
4
Joined: 28 Jan 2014, 08:30

Re: A crisis meeting in the cards?

Post

Vettel Maggot wrote:
Vettel Maggot wrote:Vettel the 'neanderthal' has come out and said that he thinks the new engines sound 'shite.'
"It's shite," he said. "That's my opinion and I think for the fans as well. I think Formula One has to be spectacular and the sound is one of the most important things.

"When I was a small child, I don't remember much, but I remember when I was six years old and we went to see the cars live during free practice, the one thing I remember was the sound. How loud they were, to feel the cars through the ground and the whole ground was vibrating. It's a shame you don't have that."

Read more at http://en.espnf1.com/redbull/motorsport ... vxY0Wzh.99
Not sure why I got a warning for this post from flyboy but what I was pointing out was its silly to call people who do not share the same view as others 'Neanderthals' as Sebp did.

Vettel has his opinion and good luck to him as do others. No need for name calling.

flyboy2160
flyboy2160
84
Joined: 25 Apr 2011, 17:05

Re: A crisis meeting in the cards?

Post

Vettel Maggot wrote:
Vettel Maggot wrote:Vettel the 'neanderthal' has come out and said that he thinks the new engines sound 'shite.'
....
Not sure why I got a warning for this post from flyboy but what I was pointing out was its silly to call people who do not share the same view as others 'Neanderthals'

Vettel has his opinion and good luck to him as do others. No need for name calling.
It wasn't clear to me that you were quoting somebody else calling Vettel a Neanderthal and saying it was silly; If that was your intention, no problemo; I agree.

Whoever else started it, please stop. It just ignites flame wars.

On to a race weekend! Free practice on TV in a couple of hours!

Flyboy Steve

Vettel Maggot
Vettel Maggot
4
Joined: 28 Jan 2014, 08:30

Re: A crisis meeting in the cards?

Post

No worries! All good.

xpensive
xpensive
214
Joined: 22 Nov 2008, 18:06
Location: Somewhere in Scandinavia

Re: A crisis meeting in the cards?

Post

beelsebob wrote: ...
Well of course he has – he's RedBull's mouth piece, and it's in their interests to make sure that the old formula comes back.
That's a thought, I wouldn't be surprised to see it shortlived, F1 is a commercial show and without appeal to the audience,
no sponsors and that would be it. Surely Mercedes will leave as soon as they have taken the 2014 WDC ansd WCC anyway.

This formula must be the most ill-conceived move by the FIA ever, which means quite a lot actually.
"I spent most of my money on wine and women...I wasted the rest"

User avatar
MOWOG
24
Joined: 07 Apr 2013, 15:46
Location: Rhode Island, USA

Re: A crisis meeting in the cards?

Post

I don't think the current formula is going to change any time soon. Too many $$$$$$$$$ invested to just toss it all in the trash and start over. After all, it took almost a decade to get rid of the Max Mosely mandated "lawn tractor" grooved tires. :oops:

in my estimation, the responsibility for this mess rest on the narrow shoulders of Jean Todt. He is a weak leader and is being led around by the nose by the big hitter teams. Formula One is obsessed with technical stuff, so if you ask they what they want, of course they are going to say they want the most gee whiz, super zoomie, wicked awesome techno-bits the mind of man can conjure up. If anyone needs a hint as to what happens to a sport when the teams take the reins, he need only look at the history of CART in the US. The teams ran the show and they proceeded to run it right into the ground. That was 30 years ago and it still hasn't fully recovered. :oops:

I guess the teams can have their google eyed fun if they want. It's their sport, after all, and if the money is there to support it, God bless 'em. For myself, I am far less interested in the racing than i have been in the past. Whether that puts me in the majority or the minority, I don't really care. "I yam what I yam", as Popeye would say.

I have long wondered why some smart people don't put together something i will call a Heritage F1 series, perhaps to run concurrently with the main attraction. Use only cars like Colin Chapman and Jim Clark brought to Indy or like Dan Gurney built when he was a constructor. I think people would pay to see a series like that. I know I would! :D

Image
Some men go crazy; some men go slow. Some men go just where they want; some men never go.

CHT
CHT
-6
Joined: 14 Apr 2008, 05:24

Re: A crisis meeting in the cards?

Post

A meeting is happening this week.
http://www.autosport.com/news/report.php/id/113249
Ferrari boss plans FIA talks amid worries over Formula 1 spectacle

Luca di Montezemolo and Bernie Ecclestone plan to meet with Jean Todt during the Bahrain Grand Prix to discuss potential changes that could improve the spectacle of Formula 1.

AUTOSPORT has learned that Ferrari boss di Montezemolo is unimpressed with the new fuel-efficiency regulations in the sport, and flew to a meeting with Ecclestone in London on Wednesday to kick-start urgent discussions about what can be done to make things better.

Sources with knowledge of the situation suggest that both men are in agreement that the first two races of the season have not produced the kind of dramatic racing that some had believed would come with the new 1.6-litre turbo engines.