donskar wrote:Maybe another dinosaur member of the forum (calling X; come in X) will corroborate or correct:
Back in the day, Marmorini left Ferrari when he was beaten out for the top engine post by Gilles Simon. Maybe I am being unfair, but I always felt Marmorini was a second-stringer. Where is Osamu Goto?
Then he came back to replace Simon blamed AFAIR for reliability problems. What does it tell you, that everyone is second-tier or that there are not many high-performance engine experts able to run F1 division?
Based on nothing: I initially thought that Renault and Ferrari simple failed in the beginning but I'm starting to think this new engines are so complicated and esoteric that because of expertise and costs involved it was more likely for everyone to fail - let's say equally. Recovery/turbine the problem not CE. Mercedes may be the oddity because of win at all cost approach - not simply financially sound but based on marketing/brands success. That might have been Renault's problem, I don't know about Ferrari apart from rumours of Domenicali complaining how smaller their engine division was.
Speaking of engines, Newey about engine measurements and equalisation:
"What’s not clear is that as the freeze becomes more and more solid if you like if one power unit then has an advantage over another or one is clearly behind, how that is addressed, because if you are in that position you have no way of upgrading your power unit because you’re frozen, then you’re doomed to forever be behind but I think that’s something which hopefully can be discussed and should be resolvable, particularly because the engines do all now carry or all cars carry torque sensors. Those torque sensors do seem to be a little bit noisy but basically very reliable and give a good signal and so it’s entirely possible for the FIA to look at the outputs from those torque sensors and see where everybody is, not only across engine-matched factories but also of course the variable of fuel, so if a particular engine and petroleum company has the benefit over another, then it’s able to do so and within that, it has the means, if it wishes to, to allow some equalisation for anybody that finds themselves behind in a frozen area."