But what about the talk here about that not being an allowed material to use? (As in: I don't doubt what you claim, I'm more interested in that counterclaim.)rgava wrote: ↑11 Feb 2019, 12:22Incidentally, last week I had the opportunity to get first hand confirmation of a long lasting rumour discussed several times here:
Ferrari engine does have steel pistons, and it's not the only one.
Honda is also using steel pistons from the same source.
They are not 3D printed, but steel is the material used since some time now.
Well, if it were not an allowed material then Ferrari would have been disqualified last year as they were racing their engine with steel pistons
Who said steel wasn't allowed?hurril wrote: ↑11 Feb 2019, 12:40But what about the talk here about that not being an allowed material to use? (As in: I don't doubt what you claim, I'm more interested in that counterclaim.)rgava wrote: ↑11 Feb 2019, 12:22Incidentally, last week I had the opportunity to get first hand confirmation of a long lasting rumour discussed several times here:
Ferrari engine does have steel pistons, and it's not the only one.
Honda is also using steel pistons from the same source.
They are not 3D printed, but steel is the material used since some time now.
It has been up a number of times. Doesn't matter.trinidefender wrote: ↑11 Feb 2019, 14:25Who said steel wasn't allowed?hurril wrote: ↑11 Feb 2019, 12:40But what about the talk here about that not being an allowed material to use? (As in: I don't doubt what you claim, I'm more interested in that counterclaim.)rgava wrote: ↑11 Feb 2019, 12:22Incidentally, last week I had the opportunity to get first hand confirmation of a long lasting rumour discussed several times here:
Ferrari engine does have steel pistons, and it's not the only one.
Honda is also using steel pistons from the same source.
They are not 3D printed, but steel is the material used since some time now.
Interesting, is the whole piston made from steel though or only the crown?rgava wrote: ↑11 Feb 2019, 12:22Incidentally, last week I had the opportunity to get first hand confirmation of a long lasting rumour discussed several times here:
Ferrari engine does have steel pistons, and it's not the only one.
Honda is also using steel pistons from the same source.
They are not 3D printed, but steel is the material used since some time now.
The whole piston is what I've been told. Forged and post-machinedNonserviam85 wrote: ↑11 Feb 2019, 16:50Interesting, is the whole piston made from steel though or only the crown?rgava wrote: ↑11 Feb 2019, 12:22Incidentally, last week I had the opportunity to get first hand confirmation of a long lasting rumour discussed several times here:
Ferrari engine does have steel pistons, and it's not the only one.
Honda is also using steel pistons from the same source.
They are not 3D printed, but steel is the material used since some time now.
5.16 Materials and construction – General :
5.16.1 Unless explicitly permitted for a specific application, the following materials may not be used anywhere on the power unit :
a) Magnesium based alloys.
b) Metal Matrix Composites (MMC’s).
c) Intermetallic materials.
d) Alloys containing more than 5% by weight of Platinum, Ruthenium, Iridium or Rhenium.
e) Copper based alloys containing more than 2.75% Beryllium.
f) Any other alloy class containing more than 0.25% Beryllium.
g) Tungsten base alloys.
h) Ceramics and ceramic matrix composites.
5.16.2 The restrictions in Article 5.16.1 do not apply to coatings provided the total coating thickness does not exceed 25% of the section thickness of the underlying base material in all axes. In all cases, other than under Article 5.16.3(b), the relevant coating must not exceed 0.8mm. Where the coating is based on Gold, Platinum, Ruthenium, Iridium or Rhenium, the coating thickness must not exceed 0.035mm.
5.16.3 The restrictions in Article 5.16.1(h) do not apply to the following applications :
a) Any component whose primary purpose is for electrical or thermal insulation.
b) Any coating whose primary purpose is for thermal insulation of the outside of the exhaust system.
5.16.4 Magnesium based alloys, where permitted, must be available on a non-exclusive basis and under normal commercial terms to all competitors. Only those alloys covered by ISO16220 or ISO3116 and approved by the FIA may be used.
5.17 Materials and construction – Components :
5.17.1 Pistons must respect Article 5.16. Titanium alloys are not permitted.
So I'm not sure the first two cons are really relevant as I cannot imagine it adds significant weight, but last two would be interesting to see how they get around that.PROS (compared to cast aluminum pistons)
Higher cylinder pressure limit
Higher piston temperature limit
Reduced top land height possible (reduced crevice volume)
May offer friction advantages particularly in iron block/liner engines
CONS (compared to cast aluminum pistons)
Higher cost
Weight (current)
Cooling oil flow requirement due to higher piston temperature
Potential to increase detonation sensitivity in gasoline applications
steel is 3 times the density of aluminium alloy
I imagine the piston crown underside must have extensive "ribbing" or perhaps a honeycomb structure to give it "thickness" without weight. This would also increase surface area for heat transfer to the cooling oil.Tommy Cookers wrote: ↑11 Feb 2019, 22:55. . . (and a steel piston 33% as thick as an alloy piston won't be stiff enough to behave properly). . . .