ScottB wrote: ↑18 Feb 2026, 11:45
bauc wrote: ↑18 Feb 2026, 11:35
ScottB wrote: ↑18 Feb 2026, 11:20
Sky discussing how Newey couldn't possibly have designed a dud. I will not stand for this MP4-18 erasure!
Main issue was the gearbox I think, something about overheating and damaging the floor which made the car unstable, but yes, the points stands, Newey has the best record, but he has good and bad days as all of us.
He also concluded it needed a whole new chassis due to aero instability caused by the side pods, which he eventually got to deliver via the 19B. Not getting to do that sooner, and being outvoted on the decision, is apparently the main reason he decided to leave Mclaren.
And really worth remembering that the 19B was excellent. Was very close in competitiveness to the dominant F2004, and probably would have been just as competitive overall with a top driver in the seat. Just came too late of course.
It's kind of hilarious how hard people are having to work to find some argument that Newey isn't all that great.