Nice floor shot from Brazil...AMUS
Great photodiffuser wrote: ↑10 Nov 2022, 16:55Nice floor shot from Brazil...AMUS
https://imgr1.auto-motor-und-sport.de/A ... 953073.jpg
Those are all AMuS' photos from their Thursday gallery uncredited
Assuming that they are somewhere near with the floor, the suspension would be the next performance limitation. AFAIK AMR are using AMG/Mercedes supplied rear suspension & gearbox/rear chassis, Mike Elliot has been fairly Frank in admitting that the AMG set-up is too stiff (both in springing & damping).organic wrote: ↑10 Nov 2022, 17:29Great photodiffuser wrote: ↑10 Nov 2022, 16:55Nice floor shot from Brazil...AMUS
https://imgr1.auto-motor-und-sport.de/A ... 953073.jpg
Almost identical to RB's 1st half of the season floor.. keel shape with scalloped bumps towards the front, floor fences with more than a single curvature, stepped diffuser, 2 large coupled outboard floor fences. Makes sense they'd end up with a similar floor with such similar other bodywork, but I can see why RB decided to investigate an internal data leak.. Remarkable how difference the performance is despite visual/concept similarity though.
Biggest difference is that the throat doesn't look nearly as curved as RB's, and their keel steps outboard into the throat. Might be that AMR couldn't completely swap from their "run the car very low" with the low and flat diffuser throat. Perhaps required change in chassis/packaging that was too great to do with in-season development.
You'd think that a Merc rearend would be supplied with a series of different spring you could use. Merc isn't ALWAYS gonna be running a harder setup. Kind of like the tires 5 ranges total.Stu wrote: ↑11 Nov 2022, 14:59Assuming that they are somewhere near with the floor, the suspension would be the next performance limitation. AFAIK AMR are using AMG/Mercedes supplied rear suspension & gearbox/rear chassis, Mike Elliot has been fairly Frank in admitting that the AMG set-up is too stiff (both in springing & damping).organic wrote: ↑10 Nov 2022, 17:29Great photodiffuser wrote: ↑10 Nov 2022, 16:55Nice floor shot from Brazil...AMUS
https://imgr1.auto-motor-und-sport.de/A ... 953073.jpg
Almost identical to RB's 1st half of the season floor.. keel shape with scalloped bumps towards the front, floor fences with more than a single curvature, stepped diffuser, 2 large coupled outboard floor fences. Makes sense they'd end up with a similar floor with such similar other bodywork, but I can see why RB decided to investigate an internal data leak.. Remarkable how difference the performance is despite visual/concept similarity though.
Biggest difference is that the throat doesn't look nearly as curved as RB's, and their keel steps outboard into the throat. Might be that AMR couldn't completely swap from their "run the car very low" with the low and flat diffuser throat. Perhaps required change in chassis/packaging that was too great to do with in-season development.
The whole Merc concept was designed to run slammed to the ground according to everything they've said, so maybe they designed the suspension around this idea: minimal travel and high stiffness to save weight, maximize aero of suspension, and maximize volume of diffuser? And their customers just have to live with the compromises Merc made as a result.diffuser wrote: ↑11 Nov 2022, 18:36You'd think that a Merc rearend would be supplied with a series of different spring you could use. Merc isn't ALWAYS gonna be running a harder setup. Kind of like the tires 5 ranges total.Stu wrote: ↑11 Nov 2022, 14:59Assuming that they are somewhere near with the floor, the suspension would be the next performance limitation. AFAIK AMR are using AMG/Mercedes supplied rear suspension & gearbox/rear chassis, Mike Elliot has been fairly Frank in admitting that the AMG set-up is too stiff (both in springing & damping).organic wrote: ↑10 Nov 2022, 17:29
Great photo
Almost identical to RB's 1st half of the season floor.. keel shape with scalloped bumps towards the front, floor fences with more than a single curvature, stepped diffuser, 2 large coupled outboard floor fences. Makes sense they'd end up with a similar floor with such similar other bodywork, but I can see why RB decided to investigate an internal data leak.. Remarkable how difference the performance is despite visual/concept similarity though.
Biggest difference is that the throat doesn't look nearly as curved as RB's, and their keel steps outboard into the throat. Might be that AMR couldn't completely swap from their "run the car very low" with the low and flat diffuser throat. Perhaps required change in chassis/packaging that was too great to do with in-season development.
Yeah, I don't buy that, not that I'm an expert. It's a rear suspension, it's designed to run at different ride heights and differnt springs. Surely they didn't plan to run the same stiffness at Monaco as they would at SPA.organic wrote: ↑11 Nov 2022, 18:41The whole Merc concept was designed to run slammed to the ground according to everything they've said, so maybe they designed the suspension around this idea: minimal travel and high stiffness to save weight, maximize aero of suspension, and maximize volume of diffuser? And their customers just have to live with the compromises Merc made as a result.diffuser wrote: ↑11 Nov 2022, 18:36You'd think that a Merc rearend would be supplied with a series of different spring you could use. Merc isn't ALWAYS gonna be running a harder setup. Kind of like the tires 5 ranges total.Stu wrote: ↑11 Nov 2022, 14:59
Assuming that they are somewhere near with the floor, the suspension would be the next performance limitation. AFAIK AMR are using AMG/Mercedes supplied rear suspension & gearbox/rear chassis, Mike Elliot has been fairly Frank in admitting that the AMG set-up is too stiff (both in springing & damping).
Why not? Monaco is an outlier track. Teams don't compromise their designs to run at Monaco. You won't take a weight or design penalty for the entire season, just to do well in Monaco.diffuser wrote: ↑11 Nov 2022, 18:48Yeah, I don't buy that, not that I'm an expert. It's a rear suspension, it's designed to run at different ride heights and differnt springs. Surely they didn't plan to run the same stiffness at Monaco as they would at SPA.organic wrote: ↑11 Nov 2022, 18:41The whole Merc concept was designed to run slammed to the ground according to everything they've said, so maybe they designed the suspension around this idea: minimal travel and high stiffness to save weight, maximize aero of suspension, and maximize volume of diffuser? And their customers just have to live with the compromises Merc made as a result.
Remember this is Merc we're talking about. The same team that built that trick Front suspenspension just for Monaco.AR3-GP wrote: ↑11 Nov 2022, 18:51Why not? Monaco is an outlier track. Teams don't compromise their designs to run at Monaco. You won't take a weight or design penalty for the entire season, just to do well in Monaco.diffuser wrote: ↑11 Nov 2022, 18:48Yeah, I don't buy that, not that I'm an expert. It's a rear suspension, it's designed to run at different ride heights and differnt springs. Surely they didn't plan to run the same stiffness at Monaco as they would at SPA.organic wrote: ↑11 Nov 2022, 18:41
The whole Merc concept was designed to run slammed to the ground according to everything they've said, so maybe they designed the suspension around this idea: minimal travel and high stiffness to save weight, maximize aero of suspension, and maximize volume of diffuser? And their customers just have to live with the compromises Merc made as a result.
Which trick front suspension? The POU corner lowering? Everyone had that before it was banned and it benefitted you everywhere, not just Monaco.diffuser wrote: ↑11 Nov 2022, 18:53Remember this is Merc we're talking about. The same team that built that trick Front suspenspension just for Monaco.
They had a year before everyone else. Also softter springs isn't a big deal.AR3-GP wrote: ↑11 Nov 2022, 18:54Which trick front suspension? The POU corner lowering? Everyone had that before it was banned and it benefitted you everywhere, not just Monaco.
Ok, I really didn't want to go down this road of squabbling over who did what first.