Silly Season 2013/14

Post here all non technical related topics about Formula One. This includes race results, discussions, testing analysis etc. TV coverage and other personal questions should be in Off topic chat.
User avatar
FW17
171
Joined: 06 Jan 2010, 10:56

Re: Who will replace Webber at Redbull?

Post

Wonder how Rubens Barrichello career compares with Mark Webber?

User avatar
raymondu999
54
Joined: 04 Feb 2010, 07:31

Re: Who will replace Webber at Redbull?

Post

WilliamsF1 wrote:Wonder how Rubens Barrichello career compares with Mark Webber?
I think MW ranks 3rd on rhe list of drivers who've had their teammate become WDC - a list Barrichello tops.
失败者找理由,成功者找方法

User avatar
iotar__
7
Joined: 28 Sep 2012, 12:31

Re: Who will replace Webber at Redbull?

Post

turbof1 wrote:
From Crash article: "confided in close friends" Some nice, close friends Webber has, if it's even true. He can't take a break, can he? This is classic Mateschitz/Red Bull driver support, they screw him, lie in general, lie about team orders (again), then quickly announce his possible replacements.
Again Crash got their info out of a The Daily Star article, a tabloid with very little credibility. What they call "a close friend" could just as well be a random tourist who had by chance neighbouring hotel chambers with Webber last year at Monaco. I am not saying whether or not Webber leaves, but that article is not any indication for both.

Just a friendly reminder to everyone: always check the original source of an article, and check the credibility of it. It'll help with identifying what is more likely real and what is less likely. This is especially true for English newspapers/tabloids: You have on one side the likes of The Sun, The Daily Star,... who are basicilly fancy gossip papers. On the other side you have good credible newspapers like The Guardian, The Times, etc.
I know, that's what "if it's even true" part is for. True or not the wording is funny.
WilliamsF1 wrote:Wonder how Rubens Barrichello career compares with Mark Webber?
Come on, he's not dead yet :) Different strengths and weaknesses, different teams and situations at their prime.

Going back to subject, here's my bold, uninformed prediction. After losing titles in 2013 Red Bull can't risk hiring their young drivers and get solid but not great and slightly overrated Hulkenberg.

CHT
CHT
-6
Joined: 14 Apr 2008, 05:24

Re: Who will replace Webber at Redbull?

Post

I think it will be very difficult for Lotus to stop kimi from leaving if RBR is determine to get him.

Raikkonen keeping 2014 options open
http://en.espnf1.com/lotusf1/motorsport ... 08564.html

User avatar
Cam
45
Joined: 02 Mar 2012, 08:38

Re: Who will replace Webber at Redbull?

Post

Citing Auto Bild's report, Die Welt newspaper now reports that Mateschitz has "personally presented the Australian with an offer to extend his contract".

The report added that Webber will consider the offer until August, when Red Bull's bosses Marko and Christian Horner have said consistently they will turn their attention to the team's 2014 driver lineup.
“There is only one good, knowledge, and one evil, ignorance.”
― Socrates
Ignorance is a state of being uninformed. Ignorant describes a person in the state of being unaware
who deliberately ignores or disregards important information or facts. © all rights reserved.

User avatar
WhiteBlue
92
Joined: 14 Apr 2008, 20:58
Location: WhiteBlue Country

Re: Who will replace Webber at Redbull?

Post

I find it highly unlikely that Webber will consistently beat Vettel over one season in any car. Otherwise your reasoning is ok. Webber and Mateschitz have no reason to swap the unknown evil for the known. The relationship and performance can be calculated and that is obviously enough for both of them to continue. At least I think that Webber will continue.
Formula One's fundamental ethos is about success coming to those with the most ingenious engineering and best .............................. organization, not to those with the biggest budget. (Dave Richards)

aral
aral
26
Joined: 03 Apr 2010, 22:49

Re: Who will replace Webber at Redbull?

Post

Cam wrote:
Citing Auto Bild's report, Die Welt newspaper now reports that Mateschitz has "personally presented the Australian with an offer to extend his contract".

The report added that Webber will consider the offer until August, when Red Bull's bosses Marko and Christian Horner have said consistently they will turn their attention to the team's 2014 driver lineup.
It is all vey well for anyone to say that Didi has personally presented Webber with an offer, but then admit that it is Horner and Marko who will make the decision. Mateschitz could not agree to something that he has no control over. All sounds like a bit of spin.

User avatar
Cam
45
Joined: 02 Mar 2012, 08:38

Re: Who will replace Webber at Redbull?

Post

gilgen wrote:
Cam wrote:
Citing Auto Bild's report, Die Welt newspaper now reports that Mateschitz has "personally presented the Australian with an offer to extend his contract".

The report added that Webber will consider the offer until August, when Red Bull's bosses Marko and Christian Horner have said consistently they will turn their attention to the team's 2014 driver lineup.
It is all vey well for anyone to say that Didi has personally presented Webber with an offer, but then admit that it is Horner and Marko who will make the decision. Mateschitz could not agree to something that he has no control over. All sounds like a bit of spin.
Where does it say the decision is solely in the hands if Horner and Marko? Webber has a strong relationship with Mateschitz and Horner and I would think Mateschitz has some say in the team he owns. Webber is well respected by both. Arguably he's the best person for the seat too. Stability is king. Why can't it be Webber's decision? Surely he's earned it and its not outside the realms of possibility.
“There is only one good, knowledge, and one evil, ignorance.”
― Socrates
Ignorance is a state of being uninformed. Ignorant describes a person in the state of being unaware
who deliberately ignores or disregards important information or facts. © all rights reserved.

Mysticf1
Mysticf1
0
Joined: 29 Jan 2010, 17:20

Re: Who will replace Webber at Redbull?

Post

I seem to remember an interview with Webber somewhere (sorry i don't have a link) where he spoke of the rumours of Kimi joining the team some years ago..he basically said talks got quite serious but that he (Webber) had first right of refusal and took up the contract for another year.

Now i have little to no knowledge of F1 contracts, but this makes me believe that even tho Webber consistently sticks to one year contracts..there may be more to it. Something along the lines of a performance level, points or otherwise that activate his option to extend.

Ohh and Webber has said on several occasions that he negotiates directly with Mateschitz.

I too believe he will stay on..really he would be crazy not to.

User avatar
Racer X
8
Joined: 21 Apr 2013, 19:04

Re: Who will replace Webber at Redbull?

Post

The question RedBull needs to answer is simple are you looking for a Number 2 driver or the beat possible line up

If you want a number 2 things are plenty simple. Get Paul Di Resta ,a Toro Rosso Driver.
If you want a top driver Take Kimi.
RedBull Racing Checo//PEREZ

User avatar
WhiteBlue
92
Joined: 14 Apr 2008, 20:58
Location: WhiteBlue Country

Re: Who will replace Webber at Redbull?

Post

gilgen wrote:It is all vey well for anyone to say that Didi has personally presented Webber with an offer, but then admit that it is Horner and Marko who will make the decision. Mateschitz could not agree to something that he has no control over. All sounds like a bit of spin.
Undoubtedly Didi makes that kind of decisions at Red Bull. If you believe different you have not understood how Red Bull operate in F1.

The main person under Didi is Newey, he runs Red Bull technology, the parent company in Britain. The company was set up totally around his preferences to lure him into the job. He makes all the decisions on how to spend the serious money. Nothing goes in RBT without him giving it ok. Then you have the racing team. That is a small outsourced company which does all the things Newey does not want to be bothered with. It operates the race cars, does the PR and takes the flak when things go wrong.

Remember when Newey decided in Silverstone 2010 to give Webber's front wing to Vettel because Vettel had used the thing in their testing program and was familiar with it. Newey did not have to go out there and explain it to the press. Horner took the flak for it. That's typical for how they operate. Horner id just a mouthpiece when it comes to important decisions. He gets to play the boss and can take the silver ware when they win. But all the important stuff is decided by other people. Neither Webber nor Vettel listen to him at all when they are in an in-fight on track.

In the end you have Marko. He is just Didi's personal watch dog so that the investment in England remains under control of the Austrian corporation. He is simply Didi eyes and ears in the team.

If the report of the contract offer is correct then it is truly up to Mark to make the decision now and we all know how he will probably decide.
Formula One's fundamental ethos is about success coming to those with the most ingenious engineering and best .............................. organization, not to those with the biggest budget. (Dave Richards)

User avatar
Cam
45
Joined: 02 Mar 2012, 08:38

Re: Who will replace Webber at Redbull?

Post

Racer X wrote:The question RedBull needs to answer is simple are you looking for a Number 2 driver or the beat possible line up

If you want a number 2 things are plenty simple. Get Paul Di Resta ,a Toro Rosso Driver.
If you want a top driver Take Kimi.
I disagree. Go back and search through the statements Horner quoted in the media around the time Hamilton was sniffing around for a seat. Also the statements Horner has made since then in relation to the development drivers in Torro Rosso. Horner made it quote clear what Red Bull need in the team and who would/would not fit the very specific mould required for that team to function harmoniously. He also made it quite clear what he was looking for in the development drivers, if they were to step up. WB's post of how Newey fits in is spot on - and it's this same ethos they use throughout the team.

Stability is key - especially when the technical is about to change dramatically. Mark and Vettel hate each other - to the point they push each other over and beyond team instructions. This hatred is pushing them both to succeed. They both know it and they both realise to some point they they need it. They both know the team intimately, know the systems, know the future directions. You can't buy that - it has to be earned. You have a perfectly functional, well established, proven winning set of pieces. There is absolutely no need to change anything, unless Mark wants out. To which, Mark's just been handed a contract. That shows you where Red Bull are thinking. Do they have a plan B - of course, that's prudent. Mark is the Plan A. Always would be.
“There is only one good, knowledge, and one evil, ignorance.”
― Socrates
Ignorance is a state of being uninformed. Ignorant describes a person in the state of being unaware
who deliberately ignores or disregards important information or facts. © all rights reserved.

rayden
rayden
2
Joined: 17 Mar 2010, 07:30

Re: Who will replace Webber at Redbull?

Post

Cam wrote: Stability is key - especially when the technical is about to change dramatically. Mark and Vettel hate each other - to the point they push each other over and beyond team instructions. This hatred is pushing them both to succeed. They both know it and they both realise to some point they they need it. They both know the team intimately, know the systems, know the future directions. You can't buy that - it has to be earned. You have a perfectly functional, well established, proven winning set of pieces. There is absolutely no need to change anything, unless Mark wants out. To which, Mark's just been handed a contract. That shows you where Red Bull are thinking. Do they have a plan B - of course, that's prudent. Mark is the Plan A. Always would be.
+1
I think the team would be silly not have mark there next year.

aral
aral
26
Joined: 03 Apr 2010, 22:49

Re: Who will replace Webber at Redbull?

Post

WhiteBlue wrote:
gilgen wrote:It is all vey well for anyone to say that Didi has personally presented Webber with an offer, but then admit that it is Horner and Marko who will make the decision. Mateschitz could not agree to something that he has no control over. All sounds like a bit of spin.
Undoubtedly Didi makes that kind of decisions at Red Bull. If you believe different you have not understood how Red Bull operate in F1.
Maybe I have a good knowledge of how things are done? Didi does not make statements such as this. It is one speculative report from a paper, from an unspecified source.

RB7ate9
RB7ate9
2
Joined: 13 Jul 2011, 03:03

Re: Who will replace Webber at Redbull?

Post

Cam wrote:
Stability is key - especially when the technical is about to change dramatically. Mark and Vettel hate each other - to the point they push each other over and beyond team instructions. This hatred is pushing them both to succeed. They both know it and they both realise to some point they they need it. They both know the team intimately, know the systems, know the future directions. You can't buy that - it has to be earned. You have a perfectly functional, well established, proven winning set of pieces. There is absolutely no need to change anything, unless Mark wants out. To which, Mark's just been handed a contract. That shows you where Red Bull are thinking. Do they have a plan B - of course, that's prudent. Mark is the Plan A. Always would be.
Frankly, they missed the window to get a replacement for Webber. The ideal time would have been either in 2012 or this year. With the new regulations in 2014, a new driver would have to first be acclimated to time at Red Bull first - getting every other aspect of the team absorbed: names, development, driver dynamics - before challenging the new regs. When the completely (relatively) new cars come in, they don't want to futz around with a new driver that can't handle the pressure when they have their own #1 adjusting as well. 2012 and especially 2013 were stable enough so that a new driver could be pulled in and advance with the notes from Vettel's side. When 2014 comes, everyone will be mostly on even ground.

Now that it's already 2013, the worse thing they can do for themselves is get someone new. Webber, even if he isn't as good as Vettel overall, has the ability to drive anything (even Marko has stated as much). For at LEAST 2014, Webber will be vital in both settling the car and collecting points. Maybe in 2015, when an entire season's worth of data is collected, Webber will be replaced.

For now, it is incredibly unwise to add yet another variable (i.e. different drivers) to the equation that is 2014.

That being said, Hulkenberg would be a good choice. Mostly because I feel sorry for him in that Sauber.