Aced wrote:Guys, you need to realize that it's not torque that's Buttons problem, it's actually a very specific way of setting up the car where he sometimes ends up with maxed front wing and an understeery car at the same time.
I just wanted to pick up on this comment back on Page 3.
I'm not going to argue what is Buttons difficulty/weakness or not, but from my understanding regarding the 2014 season and turbos, it's power delievery. In a turbo'ed car, you have a very peaky curve. Torque at the wheels might be similar to last years V8s, but the torque curve and subsequently power delivery most definately won't be.
Because of the power-delivery which will be peaky and deliver 'more torque within a smaller band' (relative to a flat curve spread out more evenly across a wider band) you will have instances where the wheels will spin up significantly, either slipping and producing oversteer. This IMO will make the 2014 cars more snappy / twitchy, which I think is what people feel might benefit a driver like Hamilton but limit a driver like Button who in the past has given an impression of not liking this behaviour. On the other side, a driver with a more sensitive input of throttle, might be able to "smoothen" the peaky delievery a bit, but on the whole, I still think a twitchy characteristic will dominate which from my understanding is what a driver like Hamilton likes.
The difference between a turbo and a naturally aspirated car is quite evident when comparing a Lotus Exige/Elise compared to an Open/Vauxhall Speedster (both same chasis, one with the Opel turbo unit and the Lotus with a Rover or Toyota/Yamaha engine), both cars roughly same peak power but the Opel with a lot more torque. Both cars have an aprox. weight distribution of 4o/60 (front/rear), but are quite neutral to drive on the track, yet the Turbo'd one will usually have more twitchy oversteer, especially when racing on a wet track where grip levels are even lower.
A more extreme example would be Caterham Super7s - where there are various models with naturally aspirated engines or turbos. The Turbos are significantly harder to drive because of the peaky power delivery in such a light chasis. Many prefer the NA ones because they are easier (and less dangerous) to drive (though less exhilirating).