2017 Mclaren F1 Team - Honda

This forum contains threads to discuss teams themselves. Anything not technical about the cars, including restructuring, performances etc belongs here.
Santozini
Santozini
5
Joined: 27 Feb 2017, 10:47

Re: 2017 Mclaren F1 Team - Honda

Post

Thunders wrote:Ok you have been warned. There is a whole Thread dedicated to the McLaren PU situation and a possible Switch to Merc / BMW. Please use it.

viewtopic.php?f=1&t=26051&p=684756#p684756
Fair enough, but i fail to understand why it wouldn't fit in this thread, since it is related to the Mclaren F1 team...

Anyway, thanks for warning me, but next time you can just let me know.

BosF1
BosF1
18
Joined: 19 Dec 2016, 10:27
Location: Netherlands

Re: 2017 Mclaren F1 Team - Honda

Post

McLaren already looking at a replacement for Alonso! :wink: :wink:

Double world champion Mika Hakkinen rejoins McLaren
The original Flying Finn becomes McLaren Partner Ambassador. McLaren is delighted to announce that double world champion Mika Hakkinen will take up the position of Partner Ambassador with immediate effect, in a multi-year deal.

http://www.mclaren.com/formula1/heritag ... n-3183643/

foxmulder_ms
foxmulder_ms
1
Joined: 10 Feb 2011, 20:36

Re: 2017 Mclaren F1 Team - Honda

Post

Santozini wrote:
Thunders wrote:Ok you have been warned. There is a whole Thread dedicated to the McLaren PU situation and a possible Switch to Merc / BMW. Please use it.

viewtopic.php?f=1&t=26051&p=684756#p684756
Fair enough, but i fail to understand why it wouldn't fit in this thread, since it is related to the Mclaren F1 team...

Anyway, thanks for warning me, but next time you can just let me know.

Mods here are freaking crazy.. They love meddling everything.

User avatar
diffuser
245
Joined: 07 Sep 2012, 13:55
Location: Montreal

Re: 2017 Mclaren F1 Team - Honda

Post

foxmulder_ms wrote:
Santozini wrote:
Thunders wrote:Ok you have been warned. There is a whole Thread dedicated to the McLaren PU situation and a possible Switch to Merc / BMW. Please use it.

viewtopic.php?f=1&t=26051&p=684756#p684756
Fair enough, but i fail to understand why it wouldn't fit in this thread, since it is related to the Mclaren F1 team...

Anyway, thanks for warning me, but next time you can just let me know.

Mods here are freaking crazy.. They love meddling everything.
says the person with a "-2".

I find they are fairly reasonable.

ollandos
ollandos
0
Joined: 22 May 2014, 07:28

Re: 2017 Mclaren F1 Team - Honda

Post

i write a post to make clear from my point of view about mclaren situation and future corner.....
mclaren right now is on alarm bell not only for 2017 season but for the next 3 ..until 2021 season with entry for the new engines...mercedes from the start take 2 solutions for his engine..1,split TU-CO 2.TJI ...the major benefits from 1 its a)the CO is on cooler place on engine and close to air inlets and b) weight managment.. and from tji the better energy efficiency...this route driving mercedes on top and i think the develop of this 2 every year increase the productiveness.....honda unlike they dont SPY mercedes ...and spend almost 3 years for nothing on there project...and now trying to take mercedes route ...all data and progres from the 2 race seasons and data written off and are uselless...right now how much time need to make this lay out to work and how to make the mercedes develop step to catch ?...its possible to do in less 12 months time? why mclaren can trust honda for this after 2 years speding time for nothing ? if hinda false again?..next year is the first ''frozen'' year for some parts and 2019 for all engine ...if honda false that mean mclaren on last place on grid for the next 3 years...and unsure for 2021
how mclaren with this parameter can be attractive for top stuff and driver ..???? if with new rules engine has les effect on the results and chassis-tires-driver can make the different why they cant win us customer?..looks like f1 go on that direction ..i think mclaren must wait little more honda ..and after symmer brake (6 months its huge time )if honda its on the same situation we must wait the divorse...they have 2 disaster years but stick with honda until now for the hopes...after so time the hope its death ...

User avatar
godlameroso
309
Joined: 16 Jan 2010, 21:27
Location: Miami FL

Re: 2017 Mclaren F1 Team - Honda

Post

Would you accept it if Honda starts getting it's act together by Sochi? How about if by Silverstone power is no longer a problem but rather a mediocre chassis? How would people respond when the tables turn and Mclaren becomes the sole reason the car isn't as fast as the others, what then? Do you suppose Honda would do itself a favor criticising McLaren for making an average chassis at best and publicly shopping around the paddock for a team willing to take a works engine supplier?

It really becomes a question of who needs who more, Honda doesn't need McLaren for a chassis, or to even be in F1. McLaren not only needs to be in F1, but they cannot build a power unit. So like I've said, pointing fingers and blaming is useless. The only way forward is to work together to find solutions to the problems at hand, there is no room for hubris and pride. It's just going to make failing all the more painful.
Saishū kōnā

ollandos
ollandos
0
Joined: 22 May 2014, 07:28

Re: 2017 Mclaren F1 Team - Honda

Post

godlameroso wrote:Would you accept it if Honda starts getting it's act together by Sochi? How about if by Silverstone power is no longer a problem but rather a mediocre chassis? How would people respond when the tables turn and Mclaren becomes the sole reason the car isn't as fast as the others, what then? Do you suppose Honda would do itself a favor criticising McLaren for making an average chassis at best and publicly shopping around the paddock for a team willing to take a works engine supplier?

It really becomes a question of who needs who more, Honda doesn't need McLaren for a chassis, or to even be in F1. McLaren not only needs to be in F1, but they cannot build a power unit. So like I've said, pointing fingers and blaming is useless. The only way forward is to work together to find solutions to the problems at hand, there is no room for hubris and pride. It's just going to make failing all the more painful.
honda if its last or 1st its all most the same ...the results effect more mclaren and i say for honda after summer ,,,.. if the season is a repeat of 2015 mclaren is on critical corner...mclaren losing money mclaren losing stuff mclaren losing prestige (honda have more activite to promote on others motosport series)..IMO mclaren already work (mercedes connect) the react on this scenario ...the time its not unlimited ...dont forget this ...car companies they dont have nothing to take from f1 ..a work team cost a lot for nothing ..mercedes its a team with limited time ...only as engine supplies this companys can be with out losing money in f1 ..the cost for run a team its huge ..and all other activites they dont give nothing more ..promote can have with simple supplying engines....maybe mercedes want mclaren for the future ..maybe mercedes have a plan to quit us team and stay only us supplyier ..xmm a good idea this ..mclaren mercedes renuion and honda take back his work team from mercedes...

mattia.bobbo
mattia.bobbo
2
Joined: 06 Feb 2015, 09:36

Re: 2017 Mclaren F1 Team - Honda

Post

Hey @ollandos, you are many many miles wrong, 90% of your sentences are completely wrong. F1 is a very very good investment for a car producer, and if merc, Ferrari, Renault are in, it means that's the best way to use their money. They would be putting their money elsewhere if that means more comeback for their businnes.
"Honda if it's the last or first is pretty much the same".. No need to commentate such idiocy..
"A work team cost a lot, and the reward is A LOT MORE than the costs". McLaren gained a lot with their P1 derived directly from their f1 cars.
Do you have an idea how much Mercedes, red bull and ferrari and McLaren gained from their success in f1? More than you can imagine.
Sorry, but I hate reading bullshit on a technical forum

GhostF1
GhostF1
110
Joined: 30 Aug 2016, 04:11

Re: 2017 Mclaren F1 Team - Honda

Post

@ollandos, Let's not forget that last year the McLaren chassis had a critical fault in design which became public by the end of the Japanese Grand Prix. The rear end was a mess, you'll find reports everywhere where they say they know what needs fixing, Suzuka exposed it. Honda was hardly the biggest issue by this point, it had decent chops and about par reliability and then the chassis issues came to forefront. It's easy to blame those on power delivery and again blame Honda but that's not the full story...
It really cannot be said Honda is the only issue here. I'm surprised Boullier admitted Merc engines would allow them to win. What a load of rubbish. It would not. Closer to the top for sure, but I'm sorry, top 3 would still be a no unless there were errors from the top teams.

F1 Turbo Hybrid Era... a.k.a Watch and overexaggerate Honda's foibles, let the rest of the paddock fly under the radar, maybe a bit of racing in there as well...

User avatar
diffuser
245
Joined: 07 Sep 2012, 13:55
Location: Montreal

Re: 2017 Mclaren F1 Team - Honda

Post

I think it's and idle threat from McLaren to provoke a reaction from Honda. I'm with GodLAmeroso.

I think this news on the web is bringing great Shame to Honda F1 R&D(If the tests weren't enough).

Senna77
Senna77
0
Joined: 05 Apr 2016, 08:05

Re: 2017 Mclaren F1 Team - Honda

Post

godlameroso wrote:Would you accept it if Honda starts getting it's act together by Sochi? How about if by Silverstone power is no longer a problem but rather a mediocre chassis? How would people respond when the tables turn and Mclaren becomes the sole reason the car isn't as fast as the others, what then? Do you suppose Honda would do itself a favor criticising McLaren for making an average chassis at best and publicly shopping around the paddock for a team willing to take a works engine supplier?

It really becomes a question of who needs who more, Honda doesn't need McLaren for a chassis, or to even be in F1. McLaren not only needs to be in F1, but they cannot build a power unit. So like I've said, pointing fingers and blaming is useless. The only way forward is to work together to find solutions to the problems at hand, there is no room for hubris and pride. It's just going to make failing all the more painful.
"Helmut Marko, Red Bull's special consultant, claimed Mercedes could have gained a one second per lap advantage by testing for three days between the two races. He said: "We are very unhappy. When we test for three days, we go a second faster – that's what Adrian Newey [Red Bull's designer] says. It definitely helped them – you can see that they had no tyre problems today. That's no accident."

https://www.theguardian.com/sport/2013/ ... esting-row

If this is true Mclaren basically lost all 8 days of testing. They never did any long runs at all. Not to mention the problems they had in 2015/2016 not just in testing but throughout the entire year with engines blowing up every race.

Even Newey cannot build a winning car in 1 year. A winning car is built on years and years of development. Newey started at redbull in 2006, then 2007, then 2008 and then finally the 2009 redbull started showing some serious pace. By 2010 it was now a monster. But it was a progressive month by month improvement over 4-5 years to get it to eventually become a winning package.

Basically you build on the speed layer by layer, month by month, year by year. It also took Mercedes a good 4+ years also to come good.

So if 3 days of testing is worth 1 second a lap according to Redbull. Mclaren theoriticaly/possibly is now 2 seconds behind on the chassis side already just this year alone. Not to mention the last 2 years this has been going on.

Instead of building every year going faster and faster layer by layer. Mclaren has been cripped from 2015 with no testing at all. Then all year they kept having issues in every single practise session and race. While other teams are gathering data etc Mclaren was in the garage. 2015 was a disaster 8 days of testing gone, 60 practise sessions crippled trying to get the dam engine to work, 20 qualifying sessions, 20 races where instead of moving forward all year they were going backwards on the chassis side stuck in the garage
Without this Mclaren would have gained 2 seconds all year easily. Then 2016 built more on that. layer by layer

Mclaren basically went backwards every weekend instead of forward.
Honda has been a total disaster for Mclaren. Especially on the chassis development side due to them missing so much track time last 2 years and still no fix in sight.

max_speed
max_speed
4
Joined: 29 Oct 2012, 04:33

Re: 2017 Mclaren F1 Team - Honda

Post

in what a mess Ron dennis has put mclaren in ?. Alonso what a unlucky guy. Honda will not get it right , in competition like F1 you need a "agile" team not a company that boasts about past a lot and has no guts to admit. Honda lack resources , knowledge , expertise and what not.
they have turned Mclaren into Manor.
i guess Mclaren has to be blamed as well , they fell into the trap of "Honda". Chasis development has suffered this much that they won't be able to recover for few years.
i guess it right they are thinking on revoking engine supply contract. Do it before Honda finishes off brand "Mclaren" left reputation.

Singabule
Singabule
17
Joined: 17 Mar 2017, 07:47

Re: 2017 Mclaren F1 Team - Honda

Post

Hi there, New in this forum. After 3 years strolling this forum, i decide to write something in this forum, sorry for my bad english mate! Im also agree with godlameroso, and i think honda is not deaf, and their pride is only the Way to move forward and to boost their morale as well. Also, for asian People, outsourcing is the Last option to solve our problem, it is Just like to share ignominy to other than your wife. Surely their Will consult but not outsource. If this gossip is True, Surely Manseour Will pay a lot of price. And i also looking forward If honda decide to jump ship to sauber, and If sauber beat mclaren in some races, Honda Will very proud of it

User avatar
RedNEO
40
Joined: 09 Jul 2016, 12:58

Re: 2017 Mclaren F1 Team - Honda

Post

Senna77 wrote:
godlameroso wrote:Would you accept it if Honda starts getting it's act together by Sochi? How about if by Silverstone power is no longer a problem but rather a mediocre chassis? How would people respond when the tables turn and Mclaren becomes the sole reason the car isn't as fast as the others, what then? Do you suppose Honda would do itself a favor criticising McLaren for making an average chassis at best and publicly shopping around the paddock for a team willing to take a works engine supplier?

It really becomes a question of who needs who more, Honda doesn't need McLaren for a chassis, or to even be in F1. McLaren not only needs to be in F1, but they cannot build a power unit. So like I've said, pointing fingers and blaming is useless. The only way forward is to work together to find solutions to the problems at hand, there is no room for hubris and pride. It's just going to make failing all the more painful.
"Helmut Marko, Red Bull's special consultant, claimed Mercedes could have gained a one second per lap advantage by testing for three days between the two races. He said: "We are very unhappy. When we test for three days, we go a second faster – that's what Adrian Newey [Red Bull's designer] says. It definitely helped them – you can see that they had no tyre problems today. That's no accident."

https://www.theguardian.com/sport/2013/ ... esting-row

If this is true Mclaren basically lost all 8 days of testing. They never did any long runs at all. Not to mention the problems they had in 2015/2016 not just in testing but throughout the entire year with engines blowing up every race.

Even Newey cannot build a winning car in 1 year. A winning car is built on years and years of development. Newey started at redbull in 2006, then 2007, then 2008 and then finally the 2009 redbull started showing some serious pace. By 2010 it was now a monster. But it was a progressive month by month improvement over 4-5 years to get it to eventually become a winning package.

Basically you build on the speed layer by layer, month by month, year by year. It also took Mercedes a good 4+ years also to come good.

So if 3 days of testing is worth 1 second a lap according to Redbull. Mclaren theoriticaly/possibly is now 2 seconds behind on the chassis side already just this year alone. Not to mention the last 2 years this has been going on.

Instead of building every year going faster and faster layer by layer. Mclaren has been cripped from 2015 with no testing at all. Then all year they kept having issues in every single practise session and race. While other teams are gathering data etc Mclaren was in the garage. 2015 was a disaster 8 days of testing gone, 60 practise sessions crippled trying to get the dam engine to work, 20 qualifying sessions, 20 races where instead of moving forward all year they were going backwards on the chassis side stuck in the garage
Without this Mclaren would have gained 2 seconds all year easily. Then 2016 built more on that. layer by layer

Mclaren basically went backwards every weekend instead of forward.
Honda has been a total disaster for Mclaren. Especially on the chassis development side due to them missing so much track time last 2 years and still no fix in sight.
Exactly!! +1000

Honda have been a total disaster from the moment they came back and I was willing to give them the benefit of the doubt the first year but in the second and especially third the excuses were starting to wear thin. They have literally no excuses as to why they failed this time, no token system to hold them back and 2 years worth of real track data to build on.

The result is an engine that rivals that 'thing' they threw together in 2015. They have screwed McLarens testing programme AGAIN which guarantees they will start the year way behind on understanding these cars which has knock on affects on development. It's literally a carbon copy of 2015. Congrats Honda on a hat-trick of turds.

User avatar
Vasconia
6
Joined: 30 Aug 2012, 10:45
Location: Basque Country

Re: 2017 Mclaren F1 Team - Honda

Post

Honda shoudl have started with a smal team, with less pressure, build a good PU over the years and then sign with a big one. Like they did in the 80s. They came late, as Senna77 has pointed out with two examples, to build a winning car requires 3-4 years of continue development AND a deep rule change like it happened in 2009 and 2014. 2017 was Honda´s chance and they have failed miserably.