Zynerji wrote: ↑02 Feb 2018, 15:30
Having built some things in my life, I can say that there are several times that I have succeeded purely by accident. The 3d metal printer I've been developing for 4 years now is only possible because of the random chance mistakes that I have made.
I can tell you a lot about my printer functionality, but that doesn't mean your brilliant reverse engineers can copy it, simply because their cat didn't knock something over, and expose an answer that was never expected. Nor did they have a child with an unrelated homework problem that just happened to be exactly the right way to solve alignment issues..
Not all understanding is from hard work. Sometimes the secret in the sauce is pure, dumb, luck.
The thing is that the probabily as well as quality of the "lucky accident" innovation is proportional to the capability, budget and number of engineers.
If the secret is indeed pure dumb luck what are the chances that Wazari has been lucky 6 times? The fact that Honda had to L&C to finish races while being massively underpowered seem to contradict that.
Anyway, what triggered me is that fact that he seemed to suggest that whatever the inventions were, they are beyond the comprehension of other engineers. I find that a bit rich considering that all other engine manufacturers (maybe bar Renault) are in a class above Honda.
Another point I always like to make is what does it take to make a winning engine ? Does it require a great deal of innovation or is it sufficient to just design everything really well within the confines of current technology ? I tend to lean toward the latter.
If you look at the DFV it did not really have any ground-breaking features. It was just really really well thought out. Nose fed cranks, stressed engines, included valve angle, compliant drives, etc had all been done before. Every now and then an AlBemet piston or prechamber injection thing comes out but even then they are really just an optimization of existing technology. Good engines are made by experienced engineers that slowly build up on a very solid foundation.
If Honda brings in dozens of green youngsters that all dream of forked rods, compressors in vee and othe nonsense but can't fix a basic torsional vibration or oil slosh issue then it is all pointless.